Validity of age estimation methods and reproducibility of bone/dental maturity indices for chronological age estimation: a systematic review and meta-analysis of validation studies

Abstract

Several approaches have been developed to estimate age, an important aspect of forensics and orthodontics, using different measures and radiological examinations. Here, through meta-analysis, we determined the validity of age estimation methods and reproducibility of bone/dental maturity indices used for age estimation. The PubMed and Google Scholar databases were searched to December 31, 2021 for human cross-sectional studies meeting pre-defined PICOS criteria that simultaneously assessed the reproducibility and validity. Meta-estimates of validity (mean error: estimated age-chronological age) and intra- and inter-observer reproducibility (Cohen’s kappa, intraclass correlation coefficient) and their predictive intervals (PI) were calculated using mixed-effect models when heterogeneity was high (I2 > 50%). The literature search identified 433 studies, and 23 met the inclusion criteria. The mean error meta-estimate (mixed effects model) was 0.08 years (95% CI − 0.12; 0.29) in males and 0.09 (95% CI − 0.12; 0.30) in females. The PI of each method spanned zero; of nine reported estimation methods, Cameriere’s had the smallest (− 0.82; 0.47) and Haavikko’s the largest (− 7.24; 4.57) PI. The reproducibility meta-estimate (fixed effects model) was 0.98 (95% CI 0.97; 1.00) for intra- and 0.99 (95% CI 0.98; 1.00) for inter-observer agreement. All methods were valid but with different levels of precision. The intra- and inter-observer reproducibility was high and homogeneous across studies.

Reliability of a forensic odontology method for age-at-death estimation in adults: A Mexican case study

“…Cohen's K statistic is commonly used for reliability assessments of categorical scales, while intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) or concordance correlation coefficient (CCC) statistics are appropriate for continuous scales [ 35 ]. The greater the difference between the results, the poorer the inter- and intra-observer reliability of the survey [ 36 ].…”

Effect of Chronic Apical Periodontitis in Primary Molars on Succedaneous Permanent Teeth: An Observational Retrospective Study

“…Nolla’s stages of calcification were used to evaluate the development of succedaneous permanent teeth using panoramic radiographs, which are extensively employed worldwide and are deemed trustworthy and precise. However, this is not without its constraints [ 14 ]. With regard to determining the placement of permanent successors, the two-dimensional nature of the panoramic film precludes accurate determination of buccal-lingual displacement.…”