Validity and Reliability of Elbow Range of Motion Measurements Using Digital Photographs, Movies, and a Goniometry Smartphone Application

Abstract

Introduction Range of motion (ROM) is closely monitored before and after surgery for stiff elbow and during rehabilitation. Measurements in the home environment may be helpful to increase involvement and adherence of the patient. Therefore, our objective is to investigate the validity and inter- and intraobserver reliability of 3 alternative methods to assess the ROM by the patient in a home-based situation, in comparison to the universal goniometer (UG). We hypothesize that all 3 alternative methods will be valid alternatives and show a level of reliability equivalent to UG. Methods Goniometric measurements of elbow flexion, extension, pronation and supination using photography, movie, and a smartphone application were obtained. The validity of these measurement methods was compared to UG. The interobserver and intraobserver reliability were calculated for all measurement methods. Results Photography and movie based goniometry of the elbow showed good validity in flexion and extension. The interobserver and intraobserver reliability were found to be good to excellent for photo and movie but moderate to poor for UG and the smartphone application. Conclusions Photo or movie based goniometry seems to be a useful option for initial and follow-up measurement of the elbow ROM, both in the outpatient clinic and in a home environment. Based on our study, the smartphone application we used is not recommended.

Percutaneous Electrolysis in the Treatment of Lateral Epicondylalgia: A Single-Blind Randomized Controlled Trial

“…This tool has shown good reliability and an MDC of 4 • to 9 • to be sure that change is not due to inter-trial variability or measurement error [23]. The inclinometer was placed on the lateral surface of the elbow, in line with the arm, to measure flexion and extension and at the third metacarpal bone to measure pronation and supination [24].…”

Accuracy and reliability of a smartphone application for measuring the knee joint angle

“…In recent years, various smartphone applications for angular measurement have been developed. These include accelerometers 6 , 7 ) , gyroscopes 8 ) , magnetometers 9 ) , and photography (photo-based type) 10 ) that measure joint angles and they have all been examined for validity and reliability. In 2017, the Japanese-language smart phone application “Grid Line Photography App Professional” (APP, Naradewa Inc) was developed for angular measurement.…”

Comparison of the Repeatability and Diagnostic Objectivity of Two Methods Of Measuring the Range of Motion in the Joints

“…devices utilizing laser or infrared beams. Testing with these devices is much less time-consuming and can be carried out more efficiently, but these devices are new on the market and in the available literature there are few reports discussing the accuracy and correctness of such an assessment of the range of motion in the joints (Stiler et al 2016;Ferriero et al 2013;Keijsers et al 2018). Therefore, the purpose of this study was to assess the repeatability and accuracy of measuring the range of motion in selected joints with the use of an infrared beam device (Hippocrates Sensor) in relation to the goniometer measurement.…”