Validation of a multiple criteria tool for healthcare facilities quality evaluation

Abstract

Purpose Several healthcare quality assessment tools measure the processes and outcomes of the care system. The actual physical infrastructure (buildings and organizational) aspects are, however, rarely considered. The purpose of this paper is to describe the process of validation and weighting of an evidence-informed framework for the quality assessment of hospital facilities from social, environmental and organizational perspectives to complement other assessments. Design/methodology/approach Sustainable High-quality Healthcare version 2 (SustHealth v2) is the updated version of an existing framework composed of three domains (social, environmental and organizational quality). To validate and establish a relevant weighting, interviews were conducted with 15 professionals within the field of healthcare planning, design, research and management. The study has been conducted through semi-structured interviews and the application of the Simon Roy Figueras (SRF) procedure for the elicitation of weights criteria. The data collected have been processed through the DecSpace web platform. Findings Among the three domains, the organizational qualities appear to be the most important (W = 49%), followed by the environmental (W = 29%) and social aspects (W = 22%). Relevant indicators such as future-proofing, wayfinding and users’ space control emerged as the most important within each macro-area. Those results are confirmed by the outcome of the interviews that highlight user/patient-centeredness, wayfinding strategies and space functionality as the most important concepts to foster in existing healthcare facilities improvement. Practical implications The study highlights important structural and organizational aspects that hospital managers and planners can consider when dealing with healthcare facilities’ quality improvement. Originality/value The use of the SRF multicriteria method is novel in this context when used to weight an assessment tool with a focus on hospital built environment.

Effect of Housing Quality on the Mental Health of University Students during the COVID-19 Lockdown

“…Studies published in recent literature have started investigating, in a systematic way, the overall quality of built environment [ 29 , 30 ] and living spaces, revealing that the absence of accessible outdoor space from the house (e.g., garden, terrace) contributed to concerning levels of psychological and behavioral symptomatology [ 31 ], confirming that housing environments could be associated with the mental health and wellbeing of residents [ 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 ]. While mental illnesses can be investigated through structured and validated scales, housing quality is mainly assessed in terms of occupants’ perception, due to the complexity of surveying a high number of different apartments and the low psychometric reliability of existing tools [ 37 , 38 , 39 , 40 , 41 ].…”

The role of the built environment in updating design requirements in the post-pandemic scenario: a case study of selected diagnostic facilities in Brazil

“…The summarised results are essential to evaluate the effectiveness of the existing design solutions and support the review of future buildings' design requirements that share the same typology, considering an evidence-based design framework (Brambilla, Lindahl, Dell'Ovo, & Capolongo, 2021;Villa et al, 2018).…”

“…As healthcare facilities shall provide support to patients on the recovery process, the assessment of healthcare facilities design requirements assume essential importance (Brambilla et al, 2021;Elf, Anåker, Marcheschi, Sigurjónsson, & Ulrich, 2020;Zhang, Tzortzopoulos, & Kagioglou, 2019).…”

“…HBEs must also comply with the requirements to allow a patient to perform basic daily activities safely and with minimal assistance (DuBose, MacAllister, Hadi, & Sakallaris, 2018), including people with cognitive impairment, whether permanent or associated with any temporary health condition. Thus, wayfinding signage may include visible landmarks in a way that promotes location and orientation to allow a first time visitor to navigate the healthcare facility successfully, ensuring user's autonomy (Brambilla et al, 2021).…”

Hospital Construction Cost Affecting Their Lifecycle: An Italian Overview

“…Given the continually changing nature of the health sector, this requires consistent and continuous investments into new and updated facilities and equipment. Such investments offer scope to policymakers to shape hospital performance through strategic and financial decisions, although the precise opportunities depend on the ownership, funding and regulatory systems within which the specific facility falls [ 7 ]. Additionally, healthcare is always seen more by developers and investors as a valuable alternative asset class, with clinics, nursing homes and assisted homecare, which are reported among the European and Italian top trends in real estate investments.…”