Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Birth: A National Survey of U.S. Midwifery Practice

Abstract

Midwives have been providing care for women choosing vaginal birth after cesarean birth (VBAC) for over 20 years. The 1999 American College of Obstetrician Gynecologist (ACOG) guidelines and recent studies questioning the relative safety of VBAC have raised concerns about continuing to offer this option. As part of an effort to understand VBAC care provided by midwives, this study used a national survey sample to examine practices, scope, and recent changes in the provision of VBAC care. The survey, which included demographic and practice items was mailed in late 2000 to a purposeful sample of 325 midwifery practices. The return rate was 62%. Nearly all (94%) of the responding practices were providing VBAC care, and almost half of them (43%) stated that their ability to do so had changed within the past 2 years secondary to recent studies in the obstetric literature, the 1999 ACOG statement, and concerns from third-party payers. Criteria for offering VBAC are stricter, and consent forms are more extensive. Other changes included the need for additional or more intensive support services, in-house anesthesia, and surgery backup. Midwives continue to provide VBAC care, although with some increased restrictions. This study provides background for future research that will determine how midwifery care affects the rate of successful VBACs.

Inconsistent Evidence: Analysis of Six National Guidelines for Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Section

“…The outcomes of these studies highlight the influence that national bodies, such as ACOG, can have on clinical practice. Given that the changes to the ACOG guidelines were not based on high-quality evidence, but on a consensus of expert opinion, and many organizations choose not to include all ACOG's recommendations (28), the effect on the practice of VBAC across the United States raises concern.…”

Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Section: A Pilot Study of Outcomes in Women Receiving Midwifery Care

“…Providers as well as third‐party payers encouraged VBAC. Recently, the ability of midwives to offer women the option of a VBAC has been restricted in many settings 1 . Fewer hospitals and physicians are offering VBAC as an option.…”

“…Recently, the ability of midwives to offer women the option of a VBAC has been restricted in many settings. 1 Fewer hospitals and physicians are offering VBAC as an option. Consequently, cesarean birth rates are rising and VBAC rates are falling.…”

Care for Women Desiring Vaginal Birth After Cesarean

“…A national survey conducted in 2000 to 2001 reviewed the effects of the 1999 American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommendations on midwifery practice 15 . Of the 200 practices that responded to the survey, 94% (n = 188) provided care to women in labor who chose TOLAC.…”