Vaccine Hesitancy and Concerns About Vaccine Safety and Effectiveness in Shanghai, China

Abstract

Introduction: Rapidly urbanizing communities in middle-income countries could be sources of vaccine hesitancy, and could create hot spots of low vaccination coverage. This study characterizes vaccine hesitancy in Shanghai and identifies disparities in vaccine safety and efficacy concerns by residency status-a marker for recent migration into the city. Methods: Parents of children aged ≤18 years from immunization clinics in Shanghai were enrolled in summer 2019, with the data analyzed during winter 2019−2020. The paper questionnaire used the Parental Attitudes towards Childhood Vaccines scale, which included questions about vaccine safety and efficacy concerns. The primary independent variable was residency-whether an individual was a Shanghai local or a recent migrant (i.e., non-local). Linear regression models assessed the relationship between residency and vaccine safety and efficacy concerns. Results: Among 1,021 participants, 65.4% had local residency, and the remainder were urban non-locals (13.1%) or rural non-locals (21.5%). A majority of parents expressed concerns about vaccine side effects (73.8%), vaccine safety (63.9%), and vaccine effectiveness (52.4%). Compared with locals, rural non-locals were more concerned about vaccine side effects (b=0.26, 95% CI=0.07, 0.46), vaccine safety (b=0.42, 95% CI=0.19, 0.65), and vaccine effectiveness (b=0.37, 95% CI=0.16, 0.58). Conclusions: Differences in vaccine hesitancy by residency could lead to geographical and sociodemographic disparities in vaccination coverage and outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease.

Acceptability of Vaccination Against COVID-19 Among Selected Residents of the Cities of Caloocan, Malabon, and Navotas, Philippines

“…Other safety-related concerns include the potential side effects and allergic reactions that might happen to those who will be vaccinated. The findings reinforce the results of many international studies that ensuring safety from COVID-19, vaccine safety, effectiveness, and side effects are primary concerns among the public [46,47]. Therefore, any effective measures to promote COVID-19 vaccination should focus on promoting the benefits of vaccination, as well as the safety and effectiveness of the vaccines [4].…”

Sensitivity to COVID-19 Vaccine Effectiveness and Safety in Shanghai, China

“…Safety and effectiveness are the two most important indicators for evaluating a new vaccine, and new vaccines undergo substantial tests of their safety and effectiveness before and after coming onto the market [ 10 , 11 ]. Previous studies showed that most parents express concerns about side-effects, safety, and effectiveness [ 12 ]. These concerns may be even more prominent for the COVID-19 vaccine, based on the perceived speed of vaccine development.…”

The long-term success of mandatory vaccination laws at implementing the first vaccination campaign in 19thcentury rural Finland

“…Firstly, remote parishes were often more difficult to access for vaccinators and possibly less well managed than more urban parishes, a characteristic also found in contemporary societies (52). Secondly, people living in remote rural parishes might be less motivated, more hesitant or even completely opposed to vaccination (53,54). Although we observed a decline in the spatio-temporal variation in vaccination coverage, indicating improvements in the management of the vaccination campaign, the reasons behind this decline remain to be identified.…”