Utilizing Cost-Effective Determination Techniques to Authenticate Cosmetics

Abstract

(1) Background: The adulteration of cosmetics has become increasingly common, which seriously harms ordinary consumers. The counterfeit cosmetics pointed out in this study mainly refer to imitating genuine products in terms of ingredients and packaging. Ordinary consumers cannot distinguish their authenticity solely based on appearance and daily use. If there is a convenient and low-cost detection method that can expose this phenomenon of adulteration, it will be able to expose adulteration and protect the interests of consumers quickly and conveniently. (2) Methods: MALDI-TOF, GC-MS, and mid-IR were used to develop low-cost and fast methods for identifying the authenticity of cosmetics. Five types of liquid and five types of emulsion cosmetics purchased from container and wholesale markets were analyzed using the three instruments mentioned above, and their spectra and acquired data were carefully compared to determine their authenticity. MALDI-TOF and GC-MS directly tested cosmetic samples, and mid-IR spectroscopy tested the ink on the outer packaging of cosmetics. (3) Results: The data procured by MALDI-TOF can provide a representation of its product attributes; two liquid samples and one paste sample demonstrated inconsistent test outcomes with the corresponding reference samples, suggesting contamination. The results of GC-MS can illustrate the substance count within cosmetic samples; the comparison outcomes of the total ion chromatogram indicate that one paste sample was a counterfeit. The results attained from mid-IR were consonant with those acquired from the MALDI-TOF analysis and GC-MS. (4) Conclusions: These three newly developed techniques can all be effectively utilized for the task of detecting cosmetic adulteration and quality control in the manufacturing process. With regard to user-friendliness and rapidity, both MALDI-TOF and mid-IR outperform GC-MS, demonstrating consistently superior levels of detection. Conversely, GC-MS has unique advantages in identifying emulsion cosmetics containing a high amount of weak polarity and volatile substances. Consequently, these corresponding methods could serve as efficient and cost-effective ways to detect authenticity issues in real-world cosmetic products.