Utilization of Machine Learning for the Differentiation of Positional NPS Isomers with Direct Analysis in Real Time Mass Spectrometry

Abstract

The differentiation of positional isomers is a well established analytical challenge for forensic laboratories. As more novel psychoactive substances (NPSs) are introduced to the illicit drug market, robust yet efficient methods of isomer identification are needed. Although current literature suggests that Direct Analysis in Real Time–Time-of-Flight mass spectrometry (DART-ToF) with in-source collision induced dissociation (is-CID) can be used to differentiate positional isomers, it is currently unclear whether this capability extends to positional isomers whose only structural difference is the precise location of a single substitution on an aromatic ring. The aim of this work was to determine whether chemometric analysis of DART-ToF data could offer forensic laboratories an alternative rapid and robust method of differentiating NPS positional ring isomers. To test the feasibility of this technique, three positional isomer sets (fluoroamphetamine, fluoromethamphetamine, and methylmethcathinone) were analyzed. Using a linear rail for consistent sample introduction, the three isomers of each type were analyzed 96 times over an eight-week timespan. The classification methods investigated included a univariate approach, the Welch t test at each included ion; a multivariate approach, linear discriminant analysis; and a machine learning approach, the Random Forest classifier. For each method, multiple validation techniques were used including restricting the classifier to data that was only generated on one day. Of these classification methods, the Random Forest algorithm was ultimately the most accurate and robust, consistently achieving out-of-bag error rates below 5%. At an inconclusive rate of approximately 5%, a success rate of 100% was obtained for isomer identification when applied to a randomly selected test set. The model was further tested with data acquired as a part of a different batch. The highest classification success rate was 93.9%, and error rates under 5% were consistently achieved.

On the challenge of unambiguous identification of fentanyl analogs: Exploring measurement diversity using standard reference mass spectral libraries

“…A natural extension to this study is to characterize measurement diversity while leveraging replicate measurements per fentanyl analog. Having replicate measurements allow us to use a broader variety of mathematical tools [39][40][41][42], including machine learning [43,44]. However, it is worth noting that replicate measurements with ambient ionization mass spectrometry techniques, like DART-MS, may introduce additional measurement uncertainty that hinder its discriminatory power [42].…”

Expert Algorithm for Substance Identification Using Mass Spectrometry: Statistical Foundations in Unimolecular Reaction Rate Theory

“…Sigman and Clark examined the two-dimensional cross-correlations in replicate spectra of high explosives, but the cross-correlations were examined as a function of a deliberate perturbation, i.e., differing collision energies, and the cross-correlations were not used to support compound identification, unlike the present work. In mass spectrometry applications, principal component analysis (PCA) has been used in two main ways: (1) to resolve or deconvolute mass spectra of mixtures, ,,, and (2) to relate a spectrum to other classes or structures within a database. ,− The latter approach has also been used in conjunction with discriminant analysis and binary classification algorithms to enable the classification of spectra to known identities. − Finally, machine learning and artificial intelligence methods have existed since the early 1970s, and they continue to be explored as methods to both identify known compounds in a library and to propose structures for compounds that are not in a library. ,,,,− Whereas the predictive power of sophisticated computational techniques is likely to continually advance, very few of the articles described so far tackle the difficult problem of discriminating between spectrally similar compounds collected on different instruments and without reference spectra from those instruments.…”

Applications of ambient ionization mass spectrometry in 2022: An annual review

“…to differentiate isomeric novel psychoactive substances, 35 and for the analysis of psychoactive plant materials. 36 Whereas ambient ionization has a clear application in the identification of bulk and trace illicit substances, the ability to rapidly screen biological samples, such as blood and urine, is also of great interest.…”