Using the CDC Worksite Health ScoreCard to Promote Organizational Change

Abstract

Purpose: To measure the impact of tying adoption of evidence-based worksite health promotion (WHP) interventions to annual organizational strategic objectives, as measured by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Worksite Health ScoreCard (ScoreCard). Design: A prospective cohort study following Johns Hopkins Medicine (JHM) affiliates against industry-specific and large employer benchmarks from 2016-2020. Settings: JHM, the largest private employer in Maryland with facilities in Florida and the District of Columbia. Subjects: Twelve JHM affiliates representing over 40,000 employees. Intervention: A strategic objective was established annually based on the ScoreCard and organizational priorities. Measures: JHM affiliates measured their WHP efforts annually using the ScoreCard. CDC industry-specific and large employer benchmarks were collected for comparison. Analysis: ScoreCard data was assessed annually to measure deviations from CDC benchmarks, determine whether strategic objectives were met, and inform additional annual objectives. Results: JHM demonstrated improvement from 8.9 percentage points above industry-specific and 3.4 percentage points below large employer benchmarks in 2016, to 26.4 percentage points above industry-specific and 21.8 percentage points above large employer benchmarks in 2020. Conclusion: Large employers face unique challenges in implementing WHP programs. Our study suggests embedding health promotion in annual strategic objectives may alleviate these challenges by prioritizing the goal and ensuring adequate resources to be successful. There are however, some limitations on using benchmarking data for comparison.

Activating Worksites to Implement Policy, Systems, and Environmental Changes: Outcomes and Overcoming Challenges

“…Workplace organizational practices were weak in comparison to those reported in a study of healthcare and social assistance workplaces. 9 Education and health care workplaces scored higher on tobacco than the other topics-this could be attributed to existing national policies for these workplaces. Policy was the least frequently attempted and reported PSE strategy.…”

Promoting worker health and well-being: Targets for change and strategies for attaining them.

“…If front-line supervisors increase their supportive exchanges with coworkers and subordinates, many employees stand to benefit in terms of enhanced well-being (Stein et al, 2020). Finally, opinion leaders may serve as high-impact leverage points because of their ability to bring about changes in others' attitudes and behaviors, and thus the identification and inclusion of opinion leaders is often a part of frameworks supporting worker health (see, for example, Safeer et al, 2021).…”

Company-Level Assessments and Organizational Policy Recommendations for the Promotion of Physical Activity and Cardiorespiratory Fitness

“…, using data to monitor progress and inform decision making). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) Worksite Health Scorecard places physical activity alongside other health risks and health behaviors and is focused on the environmental drivers that will enable promotion of health (12,13). Scorecards that place activity promotion at the workplace alongside the need for health improvement and sustainable development represent more recent innovations in measurement.…”

“…The WISH assessment tool informs organizational priority setting and decision making by addressing working conditions (e.g., hierarchy of controls), leadership commitment and vision (e.g., clear, consistent communications, accountability), participation (e.g., providing a voice and engaging workers in decision making), comprehensive and collaborative strategies (e.g., collaboration across organizational functions), adherence (e.g., following evolving standards for prevention and control), and data-driven change (e.g., using data to monitor progress and inform decision making). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) Worksite Health Scorecard places physical activity alongside other health risks and health behaviors and is focused on the environmental drivers that will enable promotion of health (12,13). Scorecards that place activity promotion at the workplace alongside the need for health improvement and sustainable development represent more recent innovations in measurement.…”