Using Spatial Analysis to Inform Community Immunization Strategies

Abstract

Introduction:Recent pertussis outbreaks in the United States suggest our response to local disease outbreaks (eg, vaccine-preventable Bordetella pertussis) may benefit from understanding and applying spatial analytical methods that use data from immunization information systems at a subcounty level.Methods:A 2012 study on Denver, CO, residents less than 19 years of age confirmed pertussis cases and immunization information system records were geocoded and aggregated to the census tract (CT) level. An algorithm assessed whether individuals were up-to-date (UTD) for pertussis vaccines. Pearson, Spearman, and Kendall correlations assessed relations between disease incidence and pertussis vaccine coverage. Using spatial analysis software, disease incidence and UTD rates were spatially weighted, and smoothed. Global and local autocorrelations based on univariate Moran’s I spatial autocorrelation statistics evaluated whether a CT’s rate belong to a cluster based on incidence or UTD measures.Results:Overall disease incidence rate was 116.8/100 000. Assessment of pertussis vaccination coverage was available for 90% of the population. Among 134 672 Denver residents less than 19 years old, 103 496 (77%) were UTD for pertussis vaccines. Raw correlation coefficients showed weak relationships between incidence and immunization rates due to the presence of outliers. With geospatial and clustering analysis, estimates and correlation coefficients were improved with statistically significant Moran’s I values for global and local autocorrelations rejecting the null hypothesis that incidence or UTD rates were randomly distributed. With evidence indicating the presence of clusters, smoothed and weighted disease incidence and UTD rates in 144 CTs identified 21 CTs (15%) for potential public health intervention.Conclusions:Correlation of raw disease incidence and vaccine UTD rates in subcounty regions showed limited association, providing limited information for decision making. By assessing for clusters using spatial analysis methods, we identified CTs with higher incidence and lower immunization coverage for targeted public health interventions.

Public and Population Health Informatics: The Bridging of Big Data to Benefit Communities

“…With increased accessibility to health delivery data by both public health and health care professionals, there has been an increase in the use of spatial analytics to monitor and understand the spread of disease and outbreak management responses 32 . For example, geographic information systems (GIS) allow communities to better utilize public health resources by targeting a community immunization response strategy to outbreak clusters 33 , although selection bias could be an issue, particularly for those from rural settings, certain ethnic or racial groups, and those with lower socio-economic status 34 . In addition, GIS surveillance can be assisted by social media.…”

Spatial distribution of incomplete immunization among under-five children in Ethiopia: evidence from 2005, 2011, and 2016 Ethiopian Demographic and health survey data

“…Previous spatial studies have revealed the existence of spatial variation for vaccination [30][31][32]. Studies of specific vaccines in Ethiopia have also revealed the presence of spatial variation for vaccination [33][34][35].…”

Population-level alcohol consumption and suicide mortality rate in South Korea: An application of multivariable spatial regression model

“…In addition, this research applies the first order of queen as the spatial weight across spatial analyses because it indicates strong dependence than other orders of queen. Here, the queen contiguity is a type of spatial weight, which estimates the proximity of observation based on a common border or common vertices of each geographic unit of analysis (Maravi et al, 2017). When producing thematic maps for the visualization of variables, this research uses the Jenks natural breaks classification method, which minimizes each class's average deviation from the class mean and maximizes each class's deviation from the means of other groups (Chen et al, 2013).…”