Using natural language processing to support peer‐feedback in the age of artificial intelligence: A cross‐disciplinary framework and a research agenda

Abstract

Advancements in artificial intelligence are rapidly increasing. The new‐generation large language models, such as ChatGPT and GPT‐4, bear the potential to transform educational approaches, such as peer‐feedback. To investigate peer‐feedback at the intersection of natural language processing (NLP) and educational research, this paper suggests a cross‐disciplinary framework that aims to facilitate the development of NLP‐based adaptive measures for supporting peer‐feedback processes in digital learning environments. To conceptualize this process, we introduce a peer‐feedback process model, which describes learners' activities and textual products. Further, we introduce a terminological and procedural scheme that facilitates systematically deriving measures to foster the peer‐feedback process and how NLP may enhance the adaptivity of such learning support. Building on prior research on education and NLP, we apply this scheme to all learner activities of the peer‐feedback process model to exemplify a range of NLP‐based adaptive support measures. We also discuss the current challenges and suggest directions for future cross‐disciplinary research on the effectiveness and other dimensions of NLP‐based adaptive support for peer‐feedback. Building on our suggested framework, future research and collaborations at the intersection of education and NLP can innovate peer‐feedback in digital learning environments. Practitioner notesWhat is already known about this topic There is considerable research in educational science on peer‐feedback processes. Natural language processing facilitates the analysis of students' textual data. There is a lack of systematic orientation regarding which NLP techniques can be applied to which data to effectively support the peer‐feedback process. What this paper adds A comprehensive overview model that describes the relevant activities and products in the peer‐feedback process. A terminological and procedural scheme for designing NLP‐based adaptive support measures. An application of this scheme to the peer‐feedback process results in exemplifying the use cases of how NLP may be employed to support each learner activity during peer‐feedback. Implications for practice and/or policy To boost the effectiveness of their peer‐feedback scenarios, instructors and instructional designers should identify relevant leverage points, corresponding support measures, adaptation targets and automation goals based on theory and empirical findings. Management and IT departments of higher education institutions should strive to provide digital tools based on modern NLP models and integrate them into the respective learning management systems; those tools should help in translating the automation goals requested by their instructors into prediction targets, take relevant data as input and allow for evaluating the predictions.

The Impact of Artificial Intelligence Tools on Academic Writing Instruction in Higher Education: A Systematic Review

“…Potential pedagogical implications relate to issues such as scaffolding and enhanced feedback on mechanics, coherence, and argument structure (Leoste et al, 2021;Kamalov et al, 2023;Nazari et al, 2021), students access personalized learning and accessibility (Bozkurt et al, 2021;Lim et al, 2023;Tedre et al, 2021), and heightened engagement and motivation (Celik et al, 2022;Kim et al, 2022;Liang et al, 2023). In addition, AI could impact pedagogy in terms of developing critical thinking and research skills (Bauer et al, 2023;Bozkurt et al, 2021;Kim et al, 2022;), and promoting collaborative authoring and peer review that could help encourage communication and cooperative learning (Leoste et al, 2021;Xiao & Yi, 2021).…”

Natural Language Processing Influence on Digital Socialization and Linguistic Interactions in the Integration of the Metaverse in Regular Social Life

“…Natural and intuitive interactions are made possible by these companions' ability to comprehend and analyze sophisticated human language owing to the application of NLP. This feature guarantees that students can ask questions and share their ideas in the same way as they would with a live teacher, with the added benefit of receiving immediate, personalized feedback [59]. These dynamic exchanges maintain the learning process' effectiveness and stimulation.…”

La autorregulación del aprendizaje desde un enfoque de feedback entre pares: perspectivas de la IA generativa

“…Si a estrategias como el chatbot le añadimos el uso de la IA en los procesos de feedback por pares y autorregulación, algunos autores (Bauer et al, 2023) describen casos de éxito en que la IA, el uso del Lenguaje Natural y las Analíticas de Aprendizaje pueden actuar como un primer apoyo para la sistematización en la elaboración del feedback. Ello es especialmente útil para estudiantes que no tienen suficiente conocimiento sobre cómo evaluar un ensayo a partir de criterios de evaluación ya establecidos (Darvishi et al, 2022).…”