It is rare for language learners, especially young learners, to have the awareness to reflect on their language learning process. This study examines the use of critical reflective writing journals in high school. It follows the journey of two female high school students through three stages of critical reflection: reflection-inaction, reflection-on-action, and reflection-for-action. Students were encouraged to practice consistent reflection outside the classroom, writing twice or three times a week. This case study is aimed at exploring critical reflection, learning beyond the classroom, and motivation. The students applied critical thinking skills to analyze and modify their own learning. Journaling facilitated a greater sense of self-awareness in students, which enabled them to identify their own strengths and improve areas of weakness in language learning. In their view, journals were a valuable resource for studying English. Results support the adoption of critical reflection practices encouraging students to become more involved in their language learning. In becoming more responsible for their learning, students begin to make conscious choices about what they are interested in exploring further while monitoring and evaluating their progress�