Using In-Building Observations of Small-to-Large Earthquakes to Predict the Seismic Response of Structures

Abstract

The main goal of this study is to evaluate the potential value of data from weak-to-moderate earthquakes for structural response analysis. Data recorded over 18 yr by the seismic network installed in the 12-stories Grenoble City Hall Building (France) is considered. The building response is analyzed in terms of intensity measures and engineering demand parameters, and then compared with strong earthquake data recorded in Japanese buildings. The uncertainties of structural response prediction are estimated and defined in terms of “within-building” and “between-building” components in the same way as the components of the ground-motion model. Data complementarity in the response model is observed between the weak-to-moderate (France) and the moderate-to-strong (Japan) earthquake datasets, disclosing nonlinear processes (associated with resonance period elongation) that are activated in buildings during low-to-strong motion. For example, fundamental frequency shifts are triggered at low values of both total structural drift amplitudes and equivalent strain rates (i.e., time derivative of structural drift). In addition, strain rate thresholds from 10−11 s−1 to 10−5 s−1 representing different structural conditions from undamaged to severely damaged buildings are observed to activate nonlinearities. This confirms the link between loading rates and structural conditions. Our results highlight the interest in instrumentation in buildings located in regions of weak-to-moderate seismicity, for (1) the development and calibration of realistic models for predicting the seismic response of structures, (2) for improving our understanding of the components of uncertainties in the risk assessment of existing buildings, and (3) to investigate physical processes activated in structures during seismic loading that influence their response.