Using gridded population and quadtree sampling units to support survey sample design in low-income settings

Abstract

Background: Household surveys are the main source of demographic, health and socioeconomic data in low-and middle-income countries (LMICs). To conduct such a survey, census population information mapped into enumeration areas (EAs) typically serves a sampling frame from which to generate a random sample. However, the use of census information to generate this sample frame can be problematic as in many LMIC contexts, such data are often outdated or incomplete, potentially introducing coverage issues into the sample frame. Increasingly, where census data are outdated or unavailable, modelled population datasets in the gridded form are being used to create household survey sampling frames. Methods: Previously this process was done by either sampling from a set of the uniform grid cells (UGC) which are then manually subdivided to achieve the desired population size, or by sampling very small grid cells then aggregating cells into larger units to achieve a minimum population per survey cluster. The former approach is time and resource-intensive as well as results in substantial heterogeneity in the output sampling units, while the latter can complicate the calculation of unbiased sampling weights. Using the context of Somalia, which has not had a full census since 1987, we implemented a quadtree algorithm for the first time to create a population sampling frame. The approach uses gridded population estimates and it is based on the idea of a quadtree decomposition in which an area successively subdivided into four equal size quadrants, until the content of each quadrant is homogenous. Results: The quadtree approach used here produced much more homogeneous sampling units than the UGC (1 × 1 km and 3 × 3 km) approach. At the national and prewar regional scale, the standard deviation and coefficient of variation, as indications of homogeneity, were calculated for the output sampling units using quadtree and UGC 1 × 1 km and 3 × 3 km approaches to create the sampling frame and the results showed outstanding performance for quadtree approach. Conclusion: Our approach reduces the manual burden of manually subdividing UGC into highly populated areas, while allowing for correct calculation of sampling weights. The algorithm produces a relatively homogenous population counts within the sampling units, reducing the variation in the weights and improving the precision of the resulting estimates. Furthermore, a protocol of creating approximately equal-sized blocks and using tablets for randomized

Representativeness of individual-level data in COVID-19 phone surveys: Findings from Sub-Saharan Africa

“…Second, using a list of phone numbers otherwise obtained, for example from a mobile network operator. Third, random digit dialing (RDD), whereby randomly generated phone numbers are called, which is used widely when no pre-existing list of phone numbers is available [ 21 ]. Phone surveys based on RDD in low- and middle-income countries have been found to suffer from significantly higher non-response rates than those based on existing contact information, which may in turn lead to greater non-response bias [ 14 , 21 ].…”

Semi-automatic mapping of pre-census enumeration areas and population sampling frames

“…In regions where data on geographic and manmade features are too sparse to obtain small enough regions after the splitting stage (either non-existent e.g., desertic areas or unmapped), a quadtree algorithm is used to further split the country. In this case, not all automated EAs follow visible boundaries, however quadtree-derived areas can then be further subdivided through a manual process (Qader et al, 2020). A visual description of this process is given in Fig.…”

Date of introduction and epidemiologic patterns of SARS-CoV-2 in Mogadishu, Somalia: estimates from transmission modelling of 2020 excess mortality data

“…To compute the baseline (pre-pandemic) crude death rate (CDR), population denominators for Mogadishu (Banadir region) were estimated using the WorldPop project’s database (19), using either the 2015 or 2019 estimates, while also adjusting for in- and out-displacement to/from the city (20). The two alternative base estimates correspond to a ‘high’ and a ‘low’ scenario with nearly identical trends (SI Figure 1) and marginally different levels (0.04-0.05 deaths/10.000 person-days) of baseline (i.e.…”