Using crime data in academic research: issues of comparability and integrity

Abstract

Purpose -Research into crime is reliant on data that is recorded and published by criminal justice agencies; data which is collected for other purposes. Considering the suitability of geocoded crime data for academic research purposes, this paper will demonstrate the difficulties faced regarding the availability, integrity and reliability of readily accessible criminal justice data. Design/methodology/approach -Data from two countries -England and Germany -were considered and set in a wider European Union (EU) context. Using the data received from requests made to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) in England and openly published reports and data available from Germany, the authors provide a contextual picture of the availability and operability of data recorded by these agencies. Geocoded data that enable cross-national comparisons with respect to immigration, ethnicity and crime are particularly hard to locate, and conducting research using data (such as crime data) whose "integrity" is questionable in an academic environment becomes increasingly problematic. Findings -Analysing secondary data produced by a number of agencies are amplified due to the different methods of collection, management, retention and dissemination. It was found that even within England, the information provided by police forces varied greatly. Data in Germany were found to be more openly available and published electronically by a number of different criminal justice agencies; however, many of the issues apparent in English data regarding data integrity were also identified here. Originality/value -The need for good record-keeping and information sharing practices has taken on added significance in today's global environment. The better availability of comparable criminal justice data has the potential to provide academics with increased opportunities to develop an evidence base for policymaking.

Life-threatening alcohol-related traffic crashes in adverse weather: a double-matched case–control analysis from Canada

“…Our analysis also lacks data on traffic volumes, distances, speeds, spacing and finer weather details at exact crash sites 49. Finally, the background degree of traffic enforcement is uncertain, fluctuates on an hourly basis and stays confidential to avoid subterfuge 50 51…”

Intra‐Eu Migration and Crime: A Jigsaw to be Reckoned with

“…Good data on both migration and crime are hard to find, many countries do not publish detailed information relating to foreign offending beyond a national level (Ludwig & Marshall ). Statistics published on migration are usually ‘deprived of information on their spatial (regional) origin or destination’ and researchers try to estimate patterns using other demographic data (Kupiszewska et al .…”

¿Realmente theft quiere decir hurto? y otras equivalencias dudosas entre las definiciones legales y criminológicas de las infracciones: Consecuencias para el estudio de la delincuencia

“…Mientras tanto, las estadísticas criminales seguirán siendo utilizadas como indicadores indirectos de la delincuencia, y puesto que no parece haber miras de que la UE intente homogeneizarlas en un futuro próximo (De Bondt, 2014;De Bondt & Vermeulen, 2009), la contribución de este artículo puede ser útil para los criminólogos que se embarquen en comparaciones internacionales (ver, por ejemplo, los volúmenes editados por Farrington et al, 2004;Tonry, 2014;Tonry & Farrington, 2005), las utilicen en sus investigaciones (Ludwig & Marshall, 2015) e incluso para aquellos que intenten establecer hasta qué punto las cifras españolas incluidas en las estadísticas de Eurostat son comparables con las del resto de países europeos. En términos de categorías legales, la concordancia perfecta es imposible.…”