Using conservation criminology to understand the role of restaurants in the urban wild meat trade

Abstract

At unsustainable rates and in illegal contexts, the wild meat trade is a driver of species extinction; it can also threaten ecosystem services, local food security and contribute to the risk of zoonotic disease spread. The restaurant and catering sectors are understudied groups in conservation, both with regards to the legal and illegal wild meat trade and particularly in urban areas. Restaurateurs are key actors between wild meat consumers and suppliers and thus play a central role in the supply chain. This study applied a crime science hot product approach to characterize: (a) restaurateur perceptions of urban wild meat consumption; (b) wildlife species most at risk in the urban wild meat trade; and (c) the differences between restaurants in Kinshasa (Democratic Republic of the Congo) and Brazzaville (Republic of the Congo). Through focus groups in both cities, participants affirmed that in urban centers wild meat is considered a luxury item and sign of wealth. Monkeys were seen as a hot product in both cities, but we found a greater variety of hot wild meat products in Brazzaville. When looking at the differences between the restaurant tier levels, middle-tiered restaurants identified pangolin and antelopes as being hot products, rather than monkeys as with upper and lower-tiered restaurants. By applying a hot product analysis, we identified the wild meat groups most likely to be targeted by the urban wild meat trade. Findings herein offer novel opportunities to better tailor and prioritize conservation interventions against illegal trade using design against crime or other crime prevention strategies. K E Y W O R D Sbushmeat, Congo Forest Basin, elephant, hot product analysis, illegal wildlife trade, monkeys, pangolins, wildlife trafficking † The views expressed herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations.

Perceptions and uses of pangolins (Pholidota) among remote rural communities in the Republic of the Congo: A baseline study from the Odzala‐Kokoua National Park

“…Such volumes are considered to be unsustainable and threaten the majority of large African rainforest mammals (Abernethy et al, 2013). In large urban areas, bushmeat can be considered a luxury food, and a symbol of prestige notably for wealthy classes (Chausson et al, 2019; Duda et al, 2018; Gluszek et al, 2021; Mbete et al, 2011). For rural inhabitants, however, bushmeat is an essential source of food for many people, it can also provide an important source of income, and can be connected to the cultural identity and traditional beliefs of local communities (Ingram et al, 2021).…”

Quantifying Illegal Extraction of Sea Turtles in Costa Rica

“…However, more recently it has caught the attention of criminologists, leading to the emergence of the conceptual framework Conservation Criminology. This field aims to bridge the gap between the two disciplines, and allows for the principles of traditional criminology to be applied to poaching (Gluszek et al, 2021). In this context, poaching is understood to be an interaction between offenders, guardians and victims, recognising wildlife as the victim (Lemieux, 2014).…”

Voluntary consensus based geospatial data standards for the global illegal trade in wild fauna and flora

“…After the third workshop, the geospatial data standards and data dictionary were successfully deployed in the field to collect wildlife trafficking data across source, transit, and destination geographies (in Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Republic of Congo) on species including elephants, pangolins, great apes, and dwarf crocodiles 27 , 28 . The standards also fit the recently unsealed indictment against four individuals accused of trafficking wildlife and heroin and laundering proceeds together in a real estate venture (e.g., Table 2 ).…”