User Interface of Blockchain-Based Agri-Food Traceability Applications: A Review

Abstract

Blockchain technology is a secure distributed ledger for lists of transactions, which has immense potential to solve traditional agri-food supply chain issues. An increasing number of research on blockchain-based traceability applications aims to improve food quality and safety. Still, relatively few works considered user interfaces when developing and reporting their applications, which could lead to usability issues. This paper aims to address this gap by reviewing existing works from user interface perspectives. We gathered 25 review papers on blockchain or agri-food supply chain and 39 research papers that presented screenshots of user interfaces of related applications. We first reviewed 7 review papers that focused on the blockchain-based agri-food supply chain to understand the benefits and challenges in the blockchain applications. We then analyzed 14 blockchain-based agri-food traceability applications and 10 non-blockchain-based agri-food traceability applications. The analysis resulted in categorizations of 5 target user groups, 3 main approaches for collecting data, 5 main approaches for visualizing data, and a discussion of other aspects of user interfaces. However, we found insufficient details and discussions on the user interfaces and design decisions of the applications for further usability assessment. Additionally, user involvement for evaluation is lower in blockchain-based researches than in non-blockchain-based researches. This trend could lead to usability problems of blockchain applications, causing blockchain technology to be underutilized. Finally, we discussed research gaps and future research directions related to user interface design, which should be addressed to ease future blockchain adoption.

EVO-NFC: Extra Virgin Olive Oil Traceability Using NFC Suitable for Small-Medium Farms

“…Blockchain is, actually, a widely studied technology as a possible solution to the request on food quality and safety [9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18]. Blockchain technology ensures data integrity through offering trust, transparency and full traceability of the stored transaction records to agri-food value chain partners.…”

Blockchain and Cryptocurrency in Human Computer Interaction: A Systematic Literature Review and Research Agenda

“…Other work developed and evaluated a local courier service system based on smart contracts [123,124]. Tharatipyakul and Pongnumkul [126] provide a comprehensive survey on user interfaces in blockchain-based agri-food provenance tracking applications. Their work categorizes means to collect (forms, scanning, and sensors) and visualize (text, tables, timelines, graphs, and maps) provenance data.…”

“…Their work categorizes means to collect (forms, scanning, and sensors) and visualize (text, tables, timelines, graphs, and maps) provenance data. Their work reveals usability challenges and emphasizes the need to consider interface design to widen blockchain adoption in the future [126].…”

Implementation of Blockchain Consortium to Prioritize Diabetes Patients’ Healthcare in Pandemic Situations

“…Table 8 compares different IIoT devices used in the healthcare industry. Fingerprint embedded authentication solves all security issues in IoT blockchain integration [52][53][54][55][56]. It eliminates the manin-the-middle attack to protect patient privacy [57][58][59].…”