User charges in government health facilities in Kenya: effect on attendance and revenue

Abstract

In this paper we study demand effects of user charges in a district health care system using cross-sectional data from household and facility surveys. The effects are examined in public as well as in private health facilities. We also look briefly at the impact of fees on revenue and service quality in government facilities. During the period of cost-sharing in public clinics, attendance dropped by about 50%. This drop prompted the government to suspend the fees for approximately 20 months. Over the 7 months after suspension of fees, attendance at government health centres increased by 41%. The suspension further caused a notable movement of patients from the private sector to government health facilities. The revenue generated by user fees covered 2.4% of the recurrent health budget. Some 40% of the facilities did not spend the fee revenue they collected, mainly due to cumbersome procedures of expenditure approvals. The paper concludes with lessons from Kenya's experience with user charges.

The Production of Child Health in Kenya: A Structural Model of Birth Weight

“…In the early 1990s, the government increased the cost of treatment in its clinics through a reform programme known as cost-sharing (Mwabu et al, 1995) but preventive health services were provided free of charge. The positive coefficient on cost per visit suggests that the increased demand for immunizations at government clinics is a result of substituting prevention for more expensive curative care.…”

Schooling, Child Labor, and the Returns to Healthcare in Tanzania

“…This is particularly true in developing contexts, like that in which this study's empirical analysis is conducted, in which nominal fees for healthcare are heavily subsidized. Distance to the nearest facility (or alternatively, the presence of a formal-care facility in one's community) is thus a large determinant of healthcare choice in developing countries, through its effects on costs (Gertler, Locay, and Samuelson 1987;Mwabu, Mwanzia, and Liambila 1995;Mwabu 2009). …”

Millet Prices, Public Policy and Child Malnutrition

“…Case studies on Uganda, South Africa, Madagascar and Kenya provide evidence of the positive effect of the abolition of user fees on the utilisation of health services (James C. et al, 2005). The abandonment of cost recovery in health led to an increase in service utilisation by 53 per cent in Uganda, 41 per cent in Kenya, and 16 per cent in Madagascar (Burnham et al 2004;Deininger, Mpuga 2004;Fafchamps, Minten 2003;Mwabu et al 1995). A study on South Africa showed that with the introduction of free primary health care the total number of consultations for curative care doubled, while that for preventive services fell due to clinic congestion and reduced consultation times (Wilkinson et.…”