Useful and Priceless Children in Contemporary Welfare States

Abstract

This article is an exercise in historical sociology. It deals with inconsistencies, absences, and unresolved issues in understandings of children's usefulness. Demography, histories of childhood, feminist research on housework and welfare states, time-use studies, psychology, ethnography, and "new sociology of childhood" often use incompatible notions of the productivity of children's time and effort. What does and does not constitute work is also one of the most keenly contested issues between children and adults. Taken together, these debates and skirmishes are at the heart of fundamental social categories. They help constitute the distinction between children and adults, work and learning, self-care and helping others, current and future usefulness, academic excellence and mediocrity, paid and unpaid effort and time, home, school, and workplace, altruistic and commercial exchange. The bulk of the article deals with countries of the North and draws on English-language studies. The concluding section uses material on countries of the South to suggest that the "majority world" might be pioneering new understandings and practices of growing up.This article is an exercise in thinking through some inconsistencies, absences, and unresolved issues in social science understandings of the usefulness or otherwise of children and young people. 1 Above all, it is an exercise in historical sociology. Without attempting a comprehensive coverage of each discipline, I refer to representative historical, quantitative, ethnographic, and psychological studies to

“It's One of Those Things That You Do to Help the Family”

“…Boys, almost as much as girls, talked about helping with cooking and cleaning, echoing Miller's (2005) finding that boys in mother-headed, Hispanic, and African American households may do more domestic work than do boys from other families. This is evident from the following words of Nova.…”

Why Citizenship: Where, When and How Children?

“…70 It is possible to point to examples of how children assume responsibility in both the private and public spheres, undertaking various forms of work, although this varies according to factors such as cultural and socio-economic context and gender. 71 In the private sphere, an important example highlighted in the literature is the heavy responsibility taken on by children who assume the role of young carers. 72 In the public sphere, a number of research studies as well as media reports reveal a fair amount of formal and informal volunteering and social action among children and young people.…”

Sibling caringscapes: Time–space practices of caring within youth-headed households in Tanzania and Uganda

“…This reflects minority world constructions of childhood that usually depict children as ''precious rather than useful'' (Miller, 2005, p. 2). Since the 1990s, however, a growing literature has demonstrated the significant care work that children and youth undertake in families affected by chronic illness and disability in the UK, Australia and USA (Becker, 2007;Becker et al, 1998).…”