Use of Twitter during Televised Election Debates: Spanish General Election (28 April 2019) vs. French General Election (24 April 2022)

Abstract

Social media have become key in political communication, playing a crucial role in election campaigns due to their fast, ubiquitous communication. This paper focuses on the comparison of the use of the social network Twitter in Spanish and French public and commercial television stations, during the last televised debates held during their general elections (2019 and 2022). It seeks to find whether conversation and interaction with their audiences take place, and whether these meet the dialogic principles set forth by Kent and Taylor adapted to Twitter by Ribalko and Seltzer to include usefulness of information, generation of return visits and dialogic loop preservation. To do this, the content of the general Twitter profiles of two French television stations, together with their profiles focused on informative content, were analyzed before, during and after the televised election debate held on 20 April. Likewise, the Twitter profiles corresponding to two Spanish television stations, together with the profiles corresponding to their news programs, were studied before, during and after the televised election debates held on 22 and 23 April. After screening all their posts, those referring to the debate and generating the largest engagement figures were selected, in order to compare the topics covered in the televised debates with those covered in Twitter. The results reveal that the information-focused accounts originate more posts whose content is linked to the televised debates, in contrast with the general accounts. Furthermore, both the unidirectionality of their content, and the lack of dialogue and interaction between these accounts and their audiences, become apparent, in addition to the minimal occurrence of “debate about the debate” flow among users.

Research on Digital Political Communication: Electoral Campaigns, Disinformation, and Artificial Intelligence

“…The newsmaking process in media has also acquired new behaviors in the production, circulation, and reception of content, resulting in a change in "journalistic cultures." Finally, citizens have novel mechanisms for participation in electoral debates, as discussed by Fontenla-Pedreira, Maiz-Bar, and Rodríguez-Martelo [11]. However, recent research casts doubt on the potential of social networks for such participation [4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11].…”

“…Finally, citizens have novel mechanisms for participation in electoral debates, as discussed by Fontenla-Pedreira, Maiz-Bar, and Rodríguez-Martelo [11]. However, recent research casts doubt on the potential of social networks for such participation [4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11].…”