Abstract:Total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) get into surface waters from both natural and anthropogenic sources. Anthropogenic sources have been relatively well recognised but the natural emmission of nutrients into the rivers, in the case of many catchments, remains a mystery. The paper describes the possibility of using a tool, the Macromodel DNS/SWAT (Discharge Nutrient Sea/Soil and Water Assessment Tool), to estimate the concentration and load of natural background (Natural Pollutant Concentration-NPC an… Show more
“…Although estimates according to both methods were based on a similar concept, the differences reached 30% and 80% for TN and TP, respectively. In the case of NBS, an attempt was made to recreate nutrient concentrations from the pre-human period, using coefficients on the natural background in undisturbed catchments 17 according to the mass-balance method, and creating a variant scenario in a modelling approach where the entire catchment area was covered by forestry without any human activities 47 , 60 . As for ATS, which was combined in a single scenario along with NBS in the modelling simulations (A5), the data on pollutant atmospheric deposition was taken into consideration.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…In the next two scenarios (A2 and A3), concerning urban and agricultural land use, their surface areas (5 663 ha and 192 917 ha, respectively) were successively replaced by the forest land use. This procedure was based on the assumption that the forest is the primary type of land use for this catchment area 47 . In order to completely eliminate the influence of these areas, the nutrient loads from the relevant surface area occupied by forest land use were subtracted, in order to estimate the contribution of urban and agricultural land (L URB and L AGS , respectively).…”
Nitrogen and phosphorus budgeting is considered to be a key tool for policy makers and stakeholders when dealing with nutrient contamination issues, however no unified method has been employed in countries affected by this eutrophication problem. The current study offers a detailed insight into the estimations of nutrient loads and their distribution between different sources for a middle-sized agricultural catchment, with the use of two approaches: mass balance (static) and modelling (dynamic). Both methods revealed similar contributions of analysed nutrient sources, although the final estimates in the chosen calculation profile were divergent due to the various reasons related to the methods’ specificity. The advantages and disadvantages of both approaches have been specified in our study, and a hybrid solution on a local and country wide scale has been proposed.
“…Although estimates according to both methods were based on a similar concept, the differences reached 30% and 80% for TN and TP, respectively. In the case of NBS, an attempt was made to recreate nutrient concentrations from the pre-human period, using coefficients on the natural background in undisturbed catchments 17 according to the mass-balance method, and creating a variant scenario in a modelling approach where the entire catchment area was covered by forestry without any human activities 47 , 60 . As for ATS, which was combined in a single scenario along with NBS in the modelling simulations (A5), the data on pollutant atmospheric deposition was taken into consideration.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…In the next two scenarios (A2 and A3), concerning urban and agricultural land use, their surface areas (5 663 ha and 192 917 ha, respectively) were successively replaced by the forest land use. This procedure was based on the assumption that the forest is the primary type of land use for this catchment area 47 . In order to completely eliminate the influence of these areas, the nutrient loads from the relevant surface area occupied by forest land use were subtracted, in order to estimate the contribution of urban and agricultural land (L URB and L AGS , respectively).…”
Nitrogen and phosphorus budgeting is considered to be a key tool for policy makers and stakeholders when dealing with nutrient contamination issues, however no unified method has been employed in countries affected by this eutrophication problem. The current study offers a detailed insight into the estimations of nutrient loads and their distribution between different sources for a middle-sized agricultural catchment, with the use of two approaches: mass balance (static) and modelling (dynamic). Both methods revealed similar contributions of analysed nutrient sources, although the final estimates in the chosen calculation profile were divergent due to the various reasons related to the methods’ specificity. The advantages and disadvantages of both approaches have been specified in our study, and a hybrid solution on a local and country wide scale has been proposed.
“…In the next two scenarios (A2 and A3), concerning urban and agricultural land use, their surface areas (5 663 ha and 192 917 ha, respectively) were successively replaced by the forest land use. This procedure was based on the assumption that the forest is the primary type of land use for this catchment area [42] . In order to completely eliminate the in uence of these areas, the nutrient loads from the relevant surface area occupied by forest land use were subtracted, in order to estimate the contribution of forest and agricultural land (L URB and L AGS , respectively).…”
Nitrogen and phosphorus budgeting is considered to be a useful tool for policy makers and stakeholders when dealing with nutrient contamination issues. Although a variety of budgeting approaches have been employed in countries affected by this problem, the direct comparison of possible options for the same area is quite limited. The current study offers a detailed insight into the estimations of nutrient loads and their distribution between different sources for a middle-sized agricultural catchment, with the use of two approaches: mass balance method and SWAT modelling. As a result of their comparison, both methods revealed similar contributions of analysed nutrient sources, although the absolute loads were heterogeneous, which stems from drawbacks related to the quality of the monitoring data, the performance of the model and omission of some catchment processes. However, in light of the performed comparison, we suggest a hybrid solution, combining the best features of both approaches.
“…To achieve the goal of the study, i.e., to track sediment particles from their source to the deposition area, the DNS (Discharge Nutrient Sea) digital platform (Macromodel DNS) has been used as a modeling tool. The Macromodel DNS, developed at the Institute of Meteorology and Water Management-National Research Institute (Instytut Meteorologii i Gospodarki Wodnej-Państwowy Instytut Badawczy, IMGW-PIB) (Wilk et al 2018b;Wilk and Orlińska-Woźniak 2019), provides an interactive platform allowing for integration of the SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) module (version 2012) (Arnold et al 2012;Abbaspour et al 2015) with other modeling tools (modules) to track different processes of the sediment/contaminant transport in a catchment (Wilk et al 2018a;Szalińska et al 2020Szalińska et al , 2021Orlińska-Woźniak et al 2020a). The RR catchment module has been created in the SWAT module (Fig.…”
Purpose
The study tracks spatial and temporal distribution of sediment particles from their source to the deposition area in a dammed reservoir. This is particularly important due to the predicted future climate changes, which will increase the severity of problems with sediment transport, especially in catchments prone to erosion.
Methods
Analyses were performed with a monthly step for two mineral and one mineral/organic sediment fractions delivered from the Carpathian Mts. catchment (Raba River) to the drinking water reservoir (Dobczyce) by combining SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool), and AdH/PTM (Adaptive Hydraulics Model/Particle Tracking Model) modules on the digital platform—Macromodel DNS (Discharge Nutrient Sea). To take into account future changes in this catchment, a variant scenario analysis including RCP (representative concentration pathways) 4.5 and 8.5, and land use change forecasts, was performed.
Results
The differences between the two analyzed hydrological units (catchment and reservoir) have been highlighted and showed a large variability of the sediment load between months. The predicted climate changes will cause a significant increase of mineral fraction loads (silt and clay) during months with high flows. Due to the location and natural arrangement of the reservoir, silt particles will mainly affect faster loss of the first two reservoir zones capacities.
Conclusions
The increased mobility of finer particles (clay) in the reservoir may be more problematic in the future, mainly due to their binding pollutant properties, and the possible negative impact on drinking water abstraction from the last reservoir zone. Moreover, the study shows that the monthly approach to forecasting the impact of climate change on sediment loads in the reservoir is recommended, instead of a seasonal one.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.