Use of Quantum Methods with Transition State Theory:  Application to H-Atom Metathesis Reactions

Abstract

The use of quantum chemical methods to determine rate constants for some H-atom metathesis reactions using transition state theory and tunneling corrections is explored. Comparisons are made among several methods (DFT, MP2, QCISD), all of which yield similar structures and frequencies for the transition states, but quite different barrier heights. Tunneling corrections are made using either the well-known Eckart method or one based on the WKB approach. We find that we can fit the extant data by varying the barrier heights using either tunneling approach, although the WKB method is both more accurate and more labor intensive. Values of the barrier heights obtained this way are not in good agreement with those obtained from any of the quantum methods. † Part of the special issue "Harold Johnston Festschrift". The authors would like to express their gratitude to Harold Johnston for his invaluable contributions to our science and his continued inspiration.

Theoretical investigation of the kinetics for the hydrogen abstraction reaction of 1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane (HFC-134a) by chlorine radical

“…2 and S- Table 2, the rate constants from MP2 calculations are about one order of magnitude underestimated as compared to the experiment rate constants. This underestimate rate constant is likely due to the overestimate energy barriers [39]. The rate constants from CCSD(T) calculations are in better agreement with the experimental values (shown as in Fig.…”

Combined valence bond-molecular mechanics potential-energy surface and direct dynamics study of rate constants and kinetic isotope effects for the H+C2H6 reaction

“…The importance of including anharmonicity in the torsion mode for this reaction was emphasized earlier by Senosiain et al 56 and Sumathi et al 43 We will therefore pay special attention to the effect of torsional anharmonicity on the calculated reaction rates. A key difference between reaction ͑R1͒ and the reaction of H with CH 4 is that there is a torsional mode in reaction ͑R1͒ that is not present in the H + CH 4 system.…”

A shock tube study of the reaction NH2 + CH4 → NH3 + CH3 and comparison with transition state theory

“…To extrapolate a rate coefficient over an extended temperature range or to compare calculated reaction barrier heights with experimentally derived ones, it is often useful to extract a "vibrationally adiabatic" reaction barrier (V a ) from experimental data, as delineated in Senosiain et al [18]. To obtain V a accurately, the effect of quantum tunneling needs to be accounted for.…”