Use of an artificial neural network to predict head injury outcome

Abstract

Object The authors describe the artificial neural network (ANN) as an innovative and powerful modeling tool that can be increasingly applied to develop predictive models in neurosurgery. They aimed to demonstrate the utility of an ANN in predicting survival following traumatic brain injury and compare its predictive ability with that of regression models and clinicians. Methods The authors designed an ANN to predict in-hospital survival following traumatic brain injury. The model was generated with 11 clinical inputs and a single output. Using a subset of the National Trauma Database, the authors “trained” the model to predict outcome by providing the model with patients for whom 11 clinical inputs were paired with known outcomes, which allowed the ANN to “learn” the relevant relationships that predict outcome. The model was tested against actual outcomes in a novel subset of 100 patients derived from the same database. For comparison with traditional forms of modeling, 2 regression models were developed using the same training set and were evaluated on the same testing set. Lastly, the authors used the same 100-patient testing set to evaluate 5 neurosurgery residents and 4 neurosurgery staff physicians on their ability to predict survival on the basis of the same 11 data points that were provided to the ANN. The ANN was compared with the clinicians and the regression models in terms of accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and discrimination. Results Compared with regression models, the ANN was more accurate (p < 0.001), more sensitive (p < 0.001), as specific (p = 0.260), and more discriminating (p < 0.001). There was no difference between the neurosurgery residents and staff physicians, and all clinicians were pooled to compare with the 5 best neural networks. The ANNs were more accurate (p < 0.0001), more sensitive (p < 0.0001), as specific (p = 0.743), and more discriminating (p < 0.0001) than the clinicians. Conclusions When given the same limited clinical information, the ANN significantly outperformed regression models and clinicians on multiple performance measures. While this paradigm certainly does not adequately reflect a real clinical scenario, this form of modeling could ultimately serve as a useful clinical decision support tool. As the model evolves to include more complex clinical variables, the performance gap over clinicians and logistic regression models will persist or, ideally, further increase.

Comparison of the Performance of Log-logistic Regression and Artificial Neural Networks for Predicting Breast Cancer Relapse

“…Kurt et al (2008) in a retrospective study, compared the performances of classification techniques including multi-layer perceptron (MLP), radial basis function, self-organizing feature maps, logistic regression and classification and regression tree, in order to predict the presence or absence of coronary artery disease in 1245 subjects (Kurt et al, 2008). Rughani and et al used an artificial neural network to predict head injury outcome (Rughani et al, 2010). The authors describe the artificial neural network as an innovative and powerful modeling tool that can be increasingly applied to develop predictive models in neurosurgery.…”

“…The authors describe the artificial neural network as an innovative and powerful modeling tool that can be increasingly applied to develop predictive models in neurosurgery. They aimed to demonstrate the utility of an ANN in predicting survival following traumatic brain injury and compare its predictive ability with those of 2 logistic regression models and clinicians (Rughani et al, 2010).…”

A Data Mining Approach for Visual and Analytical Identification of Neurorehabilitation Ranges in Traumatic Brain Injury Cognitive Rehabilitation

“…Different statistical methodologies and predictive data mining methods have been applied to predict clinical outcomes of the rehabilitation of patients with TBI [14][15][16]. Most of these studies focus on determining survival, predicting disability or the recovery of patients, and looking for the factors that better predict the patient's condition after TBI.…”

Predicting endoscopic third ventriculostomy success in childhood hydrocephalus: an artificial neural network analysis

“…The learned network could then estimate out put for the new sets of input data. 2,12 The training, testing, and validation data sets were the same as those used with regression models; thus, there was a logistic regression and an ANN model for each training, testing, and validation data set.…”