“…Both field (Ferris et al, 1987;Konhauser et al, 1993;Bonny and Jones, 2003;Fortin and Langley, 2005;Demergasso et al, 2007) and laboratory (Macaskie et al, 2000;Warren et al, 2001;Rivadeneyra et al, 2006) studies have examined mineral formation in super-saturated systems and have found a close spatial association between bacterial cells and a range of extracellular precipitated mineral phases. Despite the increasing number of studies to claim the importance of passive cell wall biomineralization (Lowenstam and Weiner, 1989;Châtellier et al, 2001;Ben Chekroun et al, 2004;Beazley et al, 2007;Dupraz et al, 2009), the nature of the evidence to date is equivocal. A range of studies have documented associations between bacterial cells and mineral precipitates (Konhauser, 1997(Konhauser, , 1998Arp et al, 1998;Douglas and Beveridge, 1998;Warren et al, 2001;Perez-Gonzalez et al, 2010), but a spatial association in and of itself does not prove a role of the cell wall in the precipitation reaction.…”