Unresolved Water Conflicts by Water Sector Institutions in Ewaso Ng’iro North River Sub-Basin, Kenya

Abstract

Water conflicts have huge impacts on livelihoods and without proper redress, have capacity to stall economic development of a community. This paper therefore explicates the impacts of unresolved water related conflicts in Ewaso Ng’iro North River sub-basin in Kenya and their persistence despite past major institutional and policy reforms in the water sector. Repetitive unresolved water conflicts curtail the prosperity of the communities on river basins. Study objective was to assess continued unresolved conflicts albeit the numerous and robust water reforms. Mixed methods research design was adopted to capture both primary and secondary data. Game Theory supported the study explicating how water users both upstream and downstream are players whose payoffs if not transparent cause conflicts. Sampling formula was utilized to derive a sample size of 384 respondents and employed simple random sampling. Primary data were collected through structured questionnaires, Key Informant interviews, Focused Group Discussions and Transect walks. Results show that water users aware of regulations in place governing water on river basins however had weak compliance. The legal and policy reforms need to be up scaled to enhance capacity to resolve conflicts by WRUAs and WRA. Compliance to regulations governing water to be enforced by mandated institutions to curb the repetitiveness of unresolved water conflicts.
 Keywords: Ewaso Ng’iro, Institutional reforms, Water Resources, Water Users, Unresolved Conflicts.

Dryland Water Resource Conservation and Conflict Management in Loisukut Sub-catchment in Laikipia North Sub-country, Kenya

“…The sub-catchment receives an average annual rainfall of 400mm, is a water-stressed region, and while there are few perennial streams, the River Loisukut, formerly known as the Sinyai River, flows around 93 kilometers and is the sub-catchment's main source of water (Lesrima, 2019).…”

Guiding community discussions on human-water-related challenges by serious gaming in the upper Ewaso Ng’iro river basin, Kenya

“…These challenges can relate to a lack of collective action due to the individualistic nature of the communities they represent. In addition to the lack of collective actions by the communities, studies have shown that climate change, 190 rapid changes in land-use systems, and societal changes such as population increase, constantly challenge the ability of WRUAs to modify rules for water allocation (Dell'Angelo et al, 2014;Lesrima, 2019;Aarts, 2012).…”

“…This is because they face pressure from other pastoralists who immigrate from far 425 downstream in search of water and pasture while their upward emigration faces inflexible resistance from the agricultural communities in the upslopes. This can explain the manifestation of fatal seasonal conflicts observed between upstream and downstream communities in the Upper Ewaso Ng'iro catchment (Lesrima, 2019;Kiteme, 2020). Within the game environment, higher profits were realized towards the final rounds when the boardgame system was relatively stable.…”

Relational rationality in land- and water use: facing Mount Kenya in times of change

“…WRUA manage specific water sheds with the main role of monitoring water use and curbing misuse. Despite this, a large amount of water is extracted for irrigation in the up and midstream region, leaving little or no water for downstream communities, often leading to water-related conflicts (Kiteme, 2020;Lesrima et al, 2021).…”

“…Downstream communities were perceived to be neutral on most of the crops, including those with a high-water requirement. This was an unexpected result, since there is documented evidence of persistent water-related conflicts between pastoralists in the downstream and crop farmers in the upstream, originating from what downstream communities consider as excessive irrigation in the upstream region Kiteme, 2020;Lesrima et al, 2021;Mutiga et al, 2010). This could mean that although farmers were aware of the downstream communities' preferences, this awareness yielded to the need to please other reference groups.…”