Unique Barriers to Workplace Health Promotion Programs by Wage Category: A Qualitative Assessment of Secondary Data

Abstract

Purpose: To understand barriers around accessing or using workplace health promotion (WHP) programs among workers in different wage categories.
Approach: We conducted qualitative analysis of responses to three open-ended questions about WHP program participation, collected as part of an existing WHP program evaluation.
Setting: A large mid-western university.
Participants: Of the 20,000 employees emailed an online survey, 3,212 responded (16.1%). The sample was mostly female (75%), white (79%), and comprised of staff members (84%). The average age was 44 years and 67% had annual incomes <$75,001. 
Method: We used NVivo-12 Plus and two coders to apply Grounded Theory on the open-ended questions and identify emergent themes. 
Results: Although most respondents were happy with the program, differences across wage categories emerged around time, financial incentives, commute, workload, and organizational policies/support. Employees at all wage levels were enthusiastic about creating a culture of health but needed different supports to do so. For instance, higher-wage workers needed to overcome self-made time constraints, while lower-wage workers needed supervisor support to overcome coverage constraints that prevented participation. 
Conclusion: The unique participation challenges experienced by employees in different wage categories provide justification for WHP programs that can better accommodate the participation barriers of all employees. While some programs may simply require more flexible offerings, others may need to train supervisors to support and foster healthy environments.

Racial Differences in Perceptions of Genetic Wellness Programs

“…There is recent recognition that other types of wellness programs could be better designed to address participation barriers for racial and ethnic minority employees and lower-income employees. 30,31 If this opportunity were taken seriously for GWPs, they could play a positive role in helping employers achieve their racial equity goals and better align their broader workforce equity and wellbeing initiatives. Taken together, our findings suggest the following specific implications for the design and regulation of GWPs:…”

Quantifying Value of Worksite Well-Being Programs With a Health Equity Lens: It’s Time to Raise the Bar

“…Data can be used to help identify and reduce participation barriers, whether related to access, perceived value, literacy concerns or other reasons. 14 Employer and vendor reporting of health equity concerns can more directly align benefits with broader organizational DEI initiatives. Experiences with COVID-19…”

“…Data can be used to help identify and reduce participation barriers, whether related to access, perceived value, literacy concerns or other reasons. 14 Employer and vendor reporting of health equity concerns can more directly align benefits with broader organizational DEI initiatives. Experiences with COVID-19 Third, vendors can establish their marketplace credibility and attention to mitigating health inequities by voluntarily reporting the health equity impact of their existing programming using book-of-business data.…”

A German Model Project for Workplace Health Promotion—Flow of Communication, Information, and Reasons for Non-Participation in the Offered Measures

“…As we combined two independent samples in our analyses, a clear match of the companies (regarding managers (first survey) and employees (second survey)) was not possible but is suggested for further research. However, studies among managers and employees on the reasons for non-participation in WHP measures state that a major barrier for participation is indeed time constraints [48][49][50].…”