Unilateral Eye Closure and Interhemispheric EEG Asymmetry during Sleep in the Pigeon <i>(Columba livia)</i>

Abstract

Aquatic mammals (i.e., Cetaceans, eared seals and manatees) and birds show interhemispheric asymmetries (IA) in slow-wave sleep-related electroencephalographic (EEG) activity, suggesting that the depth of sleep differs between hemispheres. In birds, an association between unilateral eye closure and IA has been reported in five species from three orders (i.e., Galliformes, Charadriiformes, and Anseriformes). Moreover, unilateral eye closure has been observed during behaviorally defined sleep in 29 species from 13 avian orders, suggesting that birds in general display IA during sleep. Despite the apparent prevalence of unilateral eye closure and IA in birds, previous work did not detect IA in the pigeon, thereby challenging the conclusion that this is a general feature of birds. Using digital period amplitude analysis, an objective method for quantifying EEG power (a measure of wave amplitude) across different frequencies, we demonstrate that pigeons do, in fact, display an association between unilateral eye closure and IA. For a given hemisphere, standardized 2–4 Hz EEG power was greater when the contralateral eye was closed when compared to open. We also found that pigeons used the open eye during IA to monitor their environment. In addition, individual pigeons showed a bias for keeping one eye open more than the other. The direction (left vs. right) of this bias differed across birds, and appeared to be influenced by the structure of the surrounding environment. Finally, with the addition of pigeons (order Columbiformes), IA associated with unilateral eye closure has been recorded in four avian orders, suggesting that this form of sleep is widespread in birds.

Asymmetry and Symmetry in Brain Waves from Dolphin Left and Right Hemispheres: Some Observations after Anesthesia, during Quiescent Hanging Behavior, and during Visual Obstruction

“…These future studies should seek answers to at least four central questions: (1) how the two hemispheres alternate in their sleep-wakefulness patterns; (2) which hemispheres sleep at a given time; (3) how sleep is initiated in one hemisphere but not the other; and (4) if a form REM sleep occurs unihemispherically. Now that a body of work has developed on unihemispheric sleep in birds [Rattenborg et al, 2002] more extensive evolutionary and phylogenetic comparisons can be made.…”

The Role of Cytokines in Sleep Regulation

“…This is an important meta-finding for sleep research because it indicates that sleep is a property of any surviving group of neurons. From comparative studies, it appears that many species of birds and marine mammals exhibit unihemispheric sleep [79,80,81]. A defining characteristic of NREMS, EEG delta waves, has a local cortical origin [82].…”

Different Simultaneous Sleep States in the Hippocampus and Neocortex

“…Studies have shown that sleep intensity is locally variant [2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13] and have found unihemispheric sleep in sea mammals and birds, [14][15][16][17] but the possibility that an entire brain structure such as the hippocampus could be in another stage of sleep different than the neocortex-and that this could be a normal physiological occurrence-has not been reported.…”

“…From these initial observations, we hypothesized that these two distinct brain regions could simultaneously exist in pii: sp-00251- 16 http://dx.doi.org/10.5665/sleep.6326…”