Unhelpful Thoughts and Distress Regarding Symptoms Limit Accommodation of Musculoskeletal Pain

Abstract

BackgroundAmong people with musculoskeletal disorders, much of the variation in magnitude of incapability and pain intensity is accounted for by mental and social health opportunities rather than severity of pathology. Current questionnaires seem to combine distinct aspects of mental health such as unhelpful thoughts and distress regarding symptoms, and they can be long and burdensome. To identify personalized health strategies, it would be helpful to measure unhelpful thoughts and distress regarding symptoms at the point of care with just a few questions in a way that feels relevant to a person’s health.Questions/purposes(1) Do questions that address unhelpful thoughts and distress regarding symptoms independently account for variation in accommodation of pain? (2) Which questions best measure unhelpful thoughts and distress regarding symptoms?MethodsThis is a cross-sectional questionnaire study of people seeking care regarding upper and lower extremity conditions from one of eight specialist clinicians (one upper extremity, one arthroplasty, and one sports surgeon and their three nurse practitioners and two physician assistants) in one urban office. Between June 2020 and September 2020, 171 new and returning patients were approached and agreed to participate, and 89% (153) of patients completed all questionnaires. The most common reason for noncompletion was the use of a pandemic strategy allowing people to use their phone to finish the questionnaire, with more people leaving before completion. Women and divorced, separated, or widowed people were more likely to not complete the survey, and we specifically account for sex and marital status as potential confounders in our multivariable analysis. Forty-eight percent (73 of 153) of participants were women, with a mean age 48 ± 16 years. Participants completed demographics and the validated questionnaires: Pain Catastrophizing Scale, Negative Pain Thoughts Questionnaire, Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia, Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale, and Pain Self-Efficacy Questionnaire (a measure of accommodation to pain). In an exploratory factor analysis, we found that questions group together on four topics: (1) distress about symptoms (unhelpful feelings of worry and despair), (2) unhelpful thoughts about symptoms (such as worst-case thinking and pain indicating harm), (3) being able to plan, and (4) discomfort with uncertainty. We used a multivariable analysis, accounting for potential confounding demographics, to determine whether the identified question groupings account for variation in accommodation of pain—and thus are clinically relevant. Then, we used a confirmatory factor analysis to determine which questions best represent clinically relevant groupings of questions.ResultsAfter accounting for sex, marital status, work, and income, we found that distress and unhelpful thoughts about symptoms were independently associated with accommodation of pain, and together, they explained 60% of its variation (compared with 52% for distress alone and 40% for unhelpful tho...

What are People That Seek Care for Rotator Cuff Tendinopathy Experiencing in Their Daily Life?

“…The realization that pain is due to a gradual onset condition that is age-appropriate can be counterintuitive. A strong therapeutic relationship—one that includes trust, common understanding, and engagement—can help patients develop healthy thoughts (e.g., “Even though this hurts, I can get through it”), an adaptive mindset, and a supportive environment—all of which can limit symptom intensity and activity intolerance as one ages ( 12 , 20 , 21 ).…”

Recovery After Musculoskeletal Injury: Mental and Social Health

“…Based on this, we performed a factor analysis and identified 2 separate factors—one regarding thoughts and the other regarding feelings—addressed by these questionnaires, although the 2 factors were highly related. 24 We found that we could use just a few questions to capture distress regarding symptoms in a way that people are more likely to answer forthrightly. These items include statements such as “I feel I can't stand it anymore,” “I keep thinking about how much it hurts,” and “It's awful, and it overwhelms me.” I think we can get to just a few items, each of which feels relevant, and each serving as a point of discussion.…”

CORR Insights®: Unhelpful Thoughts and Distress Regarding Symptoms Limit Accommodation of Musculoskeletal Pain

“…The important line of research started by Teunis et al [10] should continue. Future studies should investigate the best approaches to help people with psychosocial challenges and musculoskeletal symptomatology and the efficacy of integrated multidisciplinary teams [1, 4, 5].…”

“…The authors [10] may be bringing us ever closer to identifying personal characteristics (phenotypes) and red-flag statements that can help us identify the underlying stresses that may affect a person's recovery. Still, we need to refine these questionnaires, reduce the number of questions needed to get the answers we want, and identify common phrases utilized by our patients that point to psychosocial challenges that may affect patient recovery.…”

“…What do these top-tier athletes have to do with caring for people with musculoskeletal pathology? In this month's Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research ® , Teunis and colleagues [10] argue that the experiences of these high-demand athletes are also the experiences of most patients treated for musculoskeletal conditions.…”