Unexpected medical undergraduate simulation training (UMUST): can unexpected medical simulation scenarios help prepare medical students for the transition to foundation year doctor?

Abstract

BackgroundPreparing medical students with the skills necessary to deal with emergency situations as junior doctors can be challenging due to the complexities of creating authentic ‘real life’ experiences in artificial environments. The following paper is an evaluation of the UMUST (Unexpected Medical Undergraduate Simulation Training) project; a high-fidelity simulation based training programme designed to emulate the experience of dealing with medical emergencies for final year medical students preparing for practice as Foundation Year trainees.MethodsFinal year medical students from Liverpool University who undertake their clinical placements at Blackpool Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust and St. Helens & Knowsley Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust were randomly allocated into groups and took part in a series of four unexpected simulation based scenarios. At the beginning of the week in which the scenarios ran, participants were issued with a hospital bleep which they carried with them during their placement. At an unknown time to them, the participants were bleeped to attend a simulated emergency scenario, and on arrival to the Clinical Skills and Simulation facility, members of the education team undertook a standardised simulation scenario. Each session was recorded on video which the participants subsequently watched as part of a debriefing process. An assessment tool was developed to gauge whether the participants made progress in their learning over the course of the four sessions.Focus groups were held with the participants in order to evaluate their experience of the programme, and questionnaires were later distributed to all participants once they had begun working as a Foundation Year trainee. The questionnaires asked them how relevant UMUST was in preparing them for dealing with medical emergencies.ResultsThe questionnaires and the focus groups clearly showed that the doctors felt like UMUST was very valuable in preparing them to work as junior doctors. They had enjoyed taking part in UMUST and thought was a realistic and useful part of their undergraduate training.ConclusionsThe feedback from the focus groups and the subsequent questionnaires clearly demonstrate that participants felt the UMUST programme helped to prepare them as junior doctors in terms of dealing with emergency situations.

Simulation-based training of junior doctors in handling critically ill patients facilitates the transition to clinical practice: an interview study

“…The value of algorithms and structured tools, such as the ABCDE approach; the ACCEPT algorithm for planning patient transportation; and SBAR for handing over patient information, were found to support situational awareness and decision-making in their clinical work providing tools to fall back on when loosing focus. In line with our results, gaining practice in application of ABCDE has elsewhere been cited as the primary benefit after SBT [24]. After a course for medical students, SBAR was the most cited benefit followed by NTS and ABCDE [23].…”

1HR ON-CALL — Using Simulated ON-CALL to Underpin Experiential Learning in Final Year Medical Students

“…A simulation-based approach was chosen as this teaching method fits in well with the theory of experiential learning – specifically Kolb’s learning cycle [ 9 ]. There is a growing body of evidence that shows students enjoy and engage in this style of teaching as well as show an improvement in competence of key non-technical skills [ 10 , 11 ]. We then followed the simulated experience with the use of facilitated debrief, allowing students to reflect on positive and negative experiences, using Gibb’s reflective cycle [ 12 ].…”

Simulatiom Based Education as Tool in Emergency Medicine: A Systematic Review

“…Although the training uses simulated scenarios to enact emergency situations, participants report, however, that they experienced the same anxiety level as actual situations, and the results indicate that realistic simulation helps in developing the confidence of medical students in emergencies. 6 Simulation increases the sense of preparation in medical students. Assigning participants to different functions during the simulation is a convenient way to increase the size of the group.…”

“…5 Simulation-based education programs, which avoid the need to obtain consent, therefore have an important role to play in the preparation of medical scholars. 6 The use of simulators as a form of instruction began in the 1920s in pilot training. 7 They have been used in medicine over the last two decades in the field of Anesthesiology and Reanimation, which was the first specialty to use manikins extensively for residents to practice endotracheal intubation and mask ventilation.…”