UNderstanding uptake of Immunisations in TravellIng aNd Gypsy communities (UNITING): a qualitative interview study

Abstract

Background: Gypsies, Travellers and Roma (referred to as Travellers) are less likely to access health services, including immunisation. To improve immunisation rates, we need to understand what helps and hinders individuals in these communities in taking up immunisations. Aims: (1) Investigate the barriers to and facilitators of acceptability and uptake of immunisations among six Traveller communities across four UK cities; and (2) identify possible interventions to increase uptake of immunisations in these Traveller communities that could be tested in a subsequent feasibility study. Methods: Three-phase qualitative study underpinned by the social ecological model. Phase 1: interviews with 174 Travellers from six communities: Romanian Roma (Bristol); English Gypsy/Irish Traveller (Bristol); English Gypsy (York); Romanian/Slovakian Roma (Glasgow); Scottish Showpeople (Glasgow); and Irish Traveller (London). Focus on childhood and adult vaccines. Phase 2: interviews with 39 service providers. Data were analysed using the framework approach. Interventions were identified using a modified intervention mapping approach. Phase 3: 51 Travellers and 25 service providers attended workshops and produced a prioritised list of potentially acceptable and feasible interventions. Results: There were many common accounts of barriers and facilitators across communities, particularly across the English-speaking communities. Scottish Showpeople were the most similar to the general population. Roma communities experienced additional barriers of language and being in a new country. Men, women and service providers described similar barriers and facilitators. There was widespread acceptance of childhood and adult immunisation, with current parents perceived as more positive than their elders. A minority of English-speaking Travellers worried about multiple/combined childhood vaccines, adult flu and whooping cough. Cultural concerns about vaccines offered during pregnancy and about human papillomavirus were most evident in the Bristol English Gypsy/Irish Traveller community. Language, literacy, discrimination, poor school attendance, poverty and housing were identified by Travellers and service providers as barriers for some. Trustful relationships with health professionals were important and continuity of care was valued. A few English-speaking Travellers described problems of booking and attending for immunisation. Service providers tailored their approach to Travellers, particularly the Roma. Funding cuts, NHS reforms and poor monitoring challenged their work. Five ‘top-priority’ interventions were agreed across communities and service providers to improve the immunisation among Travellers who are housed or settled on an authorised site: (1) cultural competence training for health professionals and frontline staff; (2) identification of Travellers in health records to tailor support and monitor uptake; (3) provision of a named frontline person in general practitioner practices to provide respectful and supportive service; (4) flexib...

HPV vaccination in a context of public mistrust and uncertainty: a systematic literature review of determinants of HPV vaccine hesitancy in Europe

“…In qualitative studies, a need for clearer, more transparent, and unbiased information about HPV vaccination [52][53][54][55][56][57][58][59][60][61][62][63][64][65][66][67][68][69] was identified by some participants, together with the need for more verbal, interactive communication. 52,55,57,65,69 Additionally, some participants recommended providing information in schools, for instance by organising peer discussion groups with vaccinated girls 53,[55][56][57]61,62,67,69 ; while others preferred social media or communication methods that allow more discretion. [52][53][54]62,69 Concerns about vaccine safety…”

“…Qualitative studies reported beliefs that HPV vaccination might encourage promiscuity or earlier sexual debut in young girls 61,[65][66][67]100,101,106,108,119 and that the vaccine could lead to unsafe sexual behaviour and a decrease in the use of condoms and cervical cancer screening. 55,57,63,64,66,67,80,106,108,109,119 Additionally, some participants mentioned that the vaccine is being given to girls when they are too young because they have not started to menstruate, are not yet sexually active or married, 54,57,58,61,100,108 or because they are too "naïve and immature" to give their consent. 98,103 Some also reported that it is not easy to talk about HPV vaccination with girls that are so young.…”

Engaging Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller Communities in Research: Maximizing Opportunities and Overcoming Challenges

“…Despite fewer barriers to research participation in terms of literacy and language, it was not possible to recruit to the target sample of Showpeople. Some Showpeople expressed reservations about participating in a study which viewed their needs in relation to immunization as separate from the majority population (Jackson et al, 2016).…”

Tackling the declining uptake of childhood vaccinations

“…Sometimes it pays not to make assumptions about what is driving pockets of poor vaccination, but to focus instead on helping stretched parents who may Year MMR (first dose) coverage WHO target (95%) 8 8 -8 9 8 9 -9 0 9 0 -9 1 9 1 -9 2 9 2 -9 3 9 3 -9 4 9 4 -9 5 9 5 -9 6 9 6 -9 7 9 7 -9 8 9 8 -9 9 Sarah Loving, Vaccine Knowledge Project Manager at the Oxford Vaccine Group, cites the example of an orthodox Jewish group, the Charedi, in North London, where a tailoring of the immunisation programme 7 was required to fit the needs of the community and boost vaccine rates. "The community had lower than average coverage rates and had experienced several outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases in recent years, but work with the community found this was more to do with access to immunisation services than vaccine refusal or hesitancy," says Ms Loving.…”

“…Similar work has been done to understand and evaluate barriers to vaccine uptake in travelling communities. 8 In this case, several interventions were identified as important to improve the uptake of childhood vaccines, including flexible and diverse systems for booking appointments, recalls and reminders, as well as cultural competence training for health workers, and an improved system of temporary registration at GP practices for those living on the roadside and in unauthorised encampments.…”