Understanding the impact of the cofactor swapping of isocitrate dehydrogenase over the growth phenotype of Escherichia coli on acetate by using constraint-based modeling

Abstract

It has been proposed that NADP+-specificity of isocitrate dehydrogenase (ICDH) evolved as an adaptation of microorganisms to grow on acetate as the sole source of carbon and energy. In Escherichia coli, changing the cofactor specificity of ICDH from NADP+ to NAD+ (cofactor swapping) decreases the growth rate on acetate. However, the metabolic basis of this phenotype has not been analyzed. In this work, we used constraint-based modeling to investigate the effect of the cofactor swapping of ICDH in terms of energy production, response of alternative sources of NADPH, and partitioning of fluxes between ICDH and isocitrate lyase (ICL) -a crucial bifurcation when the bacterium grows on acetate-. We generated E. coli strains expressing NAD+-specific ICDH instead of the native enzyme, and bearing the deletion of the NADPH-producing transhydrogenase PntAB. We measured their growth rate and acetate uptake rate, modeled the distribution of metabolic fluxes by Flux Balance Analysis (FBA), and quantified the specific activities of NADPH-producing dehydrogenases in central pathways. The cofactor swapping of ICDH led to one-third decrease in biomass yield, irrespective of the presence of PntAB. According to our simulations, the diminution in growth rate observed upon cofactor swapping could be explained by one-half decrease in the total production of NADPH and a lower availability of carbon for biosynthesis because of a change in the partition at the isocitrate bifurcation. Together with an increased total ATP production, this scenario resulted in a 10-fold increment in the flux of ATP not used for growing purposes. PntAB was identified as the primary NADPH balancing response, with the dehydrogenases of the oxidative branch of the Pentose Phosphate Pathway and the malic enzyme playing a role in its absence. We propose that in the context of E. coli growing on acetate, the NADP+-specificity of ICDH is a trait that impacts not only NADPH production, but also the efficient allocation of carbon and energy.

Rewiring of Metabolic Network in Mycobacterium tuberculosis During Adaptation to Different Stresses

“…One such example is the use of menaquinol over ubiquinone as a cofactor to NADH dehydrogenase under oxidative stress. Effects of the use of such alternate pathways, especially during stress alleviation in bacterial systems have been elucidated in earlier literature (Shimizu, 2013; Armingol et al, 2018). However, very few such events were noted for the stresses other than oxidative stress for M.tb .…”

Synthetic microbial communities of heterotrophs and phototrophs facilitate sustainable growth

“…Synthesis of metabolites associated with overflow and secondary metabolism (e.g., formate, ethanol, and acetate, Supplementary Figs. 3, 4) is prevented as much as possible in monocultures 42 or controlled by the energetic state of cells 43 . However, for microbial communities, the active exchange of these overflow metabolites maintains and promotes the growth of community members.…”

Dynamic resource allocation drives growth under nitrogen starvation in eukaryotes

“…To assess significant upregulation and downregulation of reactions, we sampled the solution space for each model and timepoint. Sampling was carried out using the gpSampler function of the COBRA Toolbox 23 in close proximity to the optimal solution space by constraining the LP problem to a minimum of 90% the optimal solution 53 , with a sample size of 5000 points for each timepoint. Reactions were considered to be upregulation or downregulated if the paired one-tailed (right and left respectively) Student's t test rejected the null hypothesis with a p value lower than a significance level of 0.05, with reaction flux distributions at the initial and final time points as inputs.…”

“…Pathway activity variation of core metabolism in photoautotrophic (left) and heterotrophic (right) organisms after nitrogen depletion. The solution space of the models was sampled according to a previously reported methodology53 ; employing functions available in The COBRA Toolbox (see Methods). Significant upregulations or downregulations was assessed by performing a Student's t test on the distributions of each reaction at the initial and final time points.…”