Understanding the Different Dimensions of Human Dignity: Analysis of the Decision of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Slovenia on the »Tito Street« Case

Abstract

In 2011, the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Slovenia made a historical decision on the 'Tito street' case, thereby placing human dignity at the centre of the constitutional order. A few years later, some related doubts not resolved by the Constitutional Court remain. For instance, the Court argues that an exhaustive a priori definition of human dignity is impossible since the notion depends on the development of its historical and ethical substance over time. The question thus arises of why legislation states that human dignity is universal even though it can be perceived as being a product of time and place. In this paper, we strive to answer this question by arguing that human dignity has two dimensions, initial dignity and realised dignity, and interpret the Court's decision from a new angle. Thereby, the aim of this paper is to build a conceptual framework of human dignity and discuss it from a fresh perspective as well as to prove its applicability by presenting Slovenian constitutional case law. The paper offers significant insights into the discussion and may therefore help to improve future interpretations of human dignity in the field of constitutional case law.

Student Mobility and Transnational Social Ties as Factors of Reflexivity

“…Finally, meta-reflexivity might be related to individuals confronted with contradictions that individuals need to resolve while entering different socio-cultural contexts facilitated by their mobility (Kleindeinst 2017;Valentinčič 2016). As mentioned, such contradictions might be entailed in not so much the mostly intra-European mobility of the Slovenian students but more by the greater inter-cultural contradictions students from Lebanon or from Hawai'i experience (Kovačič and Rek 2016).…”

Cultural political economy of Europe 2020: Jean Monnet Chair CPE 2020 and its impact

“…Additionally, when building policies and strategies it is important to acknowledge the relevance of cultural foundations. As some authors show (Kleindienst 2017;Kleindienst and Tomšič 2017;Kleindienst and Tomšič 2018), the relationship between institutional system and cultural platform of society is mutually reinforcing. CPE2020 was planned to achieve maximum impact with available resources by utilising the existing host institution's infrastructure and activities.…”

Meaning of Human Dignity in Works of Giovanni Pico della Mirandola

“…Koncept človekovega dostojanstva je nujno treba obravnavati v luči njegovih temeljnih dimenzij, izvornega in realiziranega dostojanstva, o čemer pričajo številna nedavna dela (Formosa, Mackenzie, 2014;Kleindienst, 2017;Kleindienst, Tomšič, 2017;Kleindienst, Tomšič, 2018). Na obstoj različnih dimenzij dostojanstva so nekateri (predvsem sodobni) avtorji že začeli opozarjati, pa čeprav ti dimenziji pogosto različno poimenujejo in interpretirajo, na primer Kateb (2011); Formosa, Mackenzie (2014); Neuhäuser, Stoecker (2014); Baertschi (2014); Sulmasy (2008); Sensen (2011).…”