Understanding the cost of power interruptions to U.S. electricity consumers

Abstract

The massive electric power blackout in the northeastern United States and Canada on August 14-15, 2003 resulted in the U.S. electricity system being called "antiquated" and catalyzed discussions about modernizing the grid. Industry sources suggested that investments of $50 to $100 billion would be needed. This report seeks to quantify an important piece of information that has been missing from these discussions: how much do power interruptions and fluctuations in power quality (power-quality events) cost U.S. electricity consumers? Accurately estimating this cost will help assess the potential benefits of investments in improving the reliability of the grid.We develop a comprehensive end-use framework for assessing the cost to U.S. electricity consumers of power interruptions and power-quality events (referred to collectively as "reliability events").The framework expresses these costs as a function of:• Number of customers by type in a region;• Frequency and type of reliability events experienced annually (including both power interruptions and power-quality events) by these customers; • Cost of reliability events; and• Vulnerability of customers to these events.The framework is designed so that its cost estimate can be improved as additional data become available.Using our framework, we estimate that the national cost of power interruptions is about $80 billion annually, based on the best information available in the public domain. However, there are large gaps in and significant uncertainties about the information currently available. Notably, we were not able to develop an estimate of power-quality events. Sensitivity analysis of some of these uncertainties suggests that the total annual cost could range from less than $30 billion to more than $130 billion. Because of this large range and the enormous cost of the decisions that may be based on this estimate, we encourage policy makers, regulators, and industry to jointly undertake the comparatively modest-cost improvements needed in the information used to estimate the cost of reliability events. Specific areas for improvement include: coordinated, nationwide collection of updated information on the cost of reliability events; consistent definition and recording of the duration and frequency of reliability events, including powerquality events; and improved information on the costs of and efforts by consumers to reduce their vulnerability to reliability events.

Copper hexacyanoferrate battery electrodes with long cycle life and high power

“…Large-scale stationary energy storage is necessary to address the challenges of frequency regulation and short-term transients that currently cost the utility industry nearly US $ 100 billion annually 5 . It will also make possible the large-scale deployment of highly variable solar and wind power sources and their integration with the power grid 3 -6 .…”

An Insurance Perspective on U.S. Electric Grid Disruption Costs

“…Equally important are business-continuity programs and financial risk-transfer mechanisms such as insurance. Yet, little has been done to determine the levels of adoption and cost-effectiveness of these strategies (LaCommare and Eto 2004).…”

Cyber-Physical Security: A Game Theory Model of Humans Interacting Over Control Systems

“…-potentially leading to economic losses by damaging customer equipment or by disrupting computers or computer-based controllers belonging to commercial or industrial customers [19]. The attacker's goals are modeled by the reward function…”

“…can cause economic loss either from equipment damage or lost productivity due to disturbances to computers or computerbased industrial controllers [19]. The likelihood of such voltage deviations is increased because possibility of attacks on the distributed generator at node 3.…”

“…In contrast to the value of energy, there is no obvious proxy for this cost making it difficult to estimate. Studies [19] have concluded that the cost is typically dominated by a few highly sensitive customers, making this cost also dependent on grid location and time -the location of the highly sensitive customers and their periods operation drive this variability. The average cost of a power quality event has been estimated [19] at roughly C P Q =$300/sensitive customer/per power quality event.…”