Understanding the complex relationships among actors involved in the implementation of public-private mix (PPM) for TB control in India, using social theory

Abstract

BackgroundPublic Private Partnerships (PPP) are increasingly utilized as a public health strategy for strengthening health systems and have become a core component for the delivery of TB control services in India, as promoted through national policy. However, partnerships are complex systems that rely on relationships between a myriad of different actors with divergent agendas and backgrounds. Relationship is a crucial element of governance, and relationship building an important aspect of partnerships. To understand PPPs a multi-disciplinary perspective that draws on insights from social theory is needed. This paper demonstrates how social theory can aid the understanding of the complex relationships of actors involved in implementation of Public-Private Mix (PPM)-TB policy in India.MethodsEthnographic research was conducted within a district in a Southern state of India over a 14 month period, combining participant observations, informal interactions and in-depth interviews with a wide range of respondents across public, private and non-government organisation (NGO) sectors.ResultsDrawing on the theoretical insights from Bourdieu’s “theory of practice” this study explores the relationships between the different actors. The study found that programme managers, frontline TB workers, NGOs, and private practitioners all had a crucial role to play in TB partnerships. They were widely regarded as valued contributors with distinct social skills and capabilities within their organizations and professions. However, their potential contributions towards programme implementation tended to be unrecognized both at the top and bottom of the policy implementation chain. These actors constantly struggled for recognition and used different mechanisms to position themselves alongside other actors within the programme that further complicated the relationships between different actors.ConclusionThis paper demonstrates that applying social theory can enable a better understanding of the complex relationship across public, private and NGO sectors. A closer understanding of these processes is a prerequisite for bridging the gap between field-level practices and central policy intentions, facilitating a move towards more effective partnership strategies for strengthening local health systems. The study contributes to our understanding of implementation of PPP for TB control and builds knowledge to help policy makers and programme managers strengthen and effectively implement strategies to enable stronger governance of these partnerships.

Key recommendations to strengthen public-private partnership for adolescent health in resource constrained settings: Formative qualitative inquiry in Mongolia, Myanmar and the Philippines

“…This is consistent with examples from PPP in the Asia Pacific focussed on adult health where private providers had access to free essential medicines and diagnostics, access to training and supervision, and branding to align the provider with the national program and generate demand. [25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37][38] This is also consistent with approaches more globally. [39] By contrast, incentives for the public sector were often less well articulated and/ or more altruistic (improved services for adolescents), but identifying these benefits were nonetheless important to ensuring enhanced partnership.…”

Barriers for involvement of private doctors in RNTCP – Qualitative study from Kerala, India

“…Many of the issues emerging from the FGDs have been documented previously also. [78] The joint monitoring mission conducted in 2009 and 2012 have shown that delays and nonpayment of reimbursements for the implementation of schemes prompted private practitioners to stay away from signing any new schemes. In addition, only 4% of the state's allocation is for PPM, and out of this only one-third is being actually spent.…”

The Political Economy of Public Health Inequalities and Inequities in India: Complexities, Challenges, and Strategies for Inclusive Public Health Care Policy

“…Also, due to a lack of funding and resources, the majority of NGOs in India have problems delivering equitable and equal health care services to the poor. NGOs have to wait for a long time to receive their payments, which decreases their motivation to work with the government [68][69][70] . However, we need to be cautious on the politics of NGOs and their functioning.…”