Understanding the cause of false negative β-d-glucuronidase reactions in culture media containing fermentable carbohydrate

Abstract

Aims: To explain the basis for false negative β‐glucuronidase reactions seen with culture media containing lactose as a carbon and energy source. Methods and Results: Escherichia coli strains were assessed for their reactions in culture media containing a β‐d‐glucuronidase substrate either with or without lactose. An assay was developed to test for the expression of β‐d‐glucuronidase at pH 5·0 and pH 7·2. Strains of E. coli that gave false negative glucuronidase reactions on media containing lactose generally expressed lower concentrations of the enzyme β‐d‐glucuronidase than strains that gave positive results, although the difference was by no means consistent. Most strains that were negative on lactose‐containing media expressed virtually no β‐d‐glucuronidase activity at pH 5·0. Examination of colonies on Membrane lactose glucuronide agar (MLGA) from lightly polluted water showed that c. 10% of the E. coli present failed to yield green colonies on MLGA. Conclusions: E. coli that failed to produce green colonies on MLGA produced lower levels of β‐d‐glucuronidase than did strains that formed green colonies, the difference being greater at pH 5·0 than pH 7·2. The false negative rate for E. coli 10% which is similar to that experienced in the study that originally described MLGA. Significance and Impact of the Study: Strains of E. coli that fail to produce typical colonies on MLGA might produce lower concentrations of the enzyme β‐d‐glucuronidase. Whilst the enzyme activity is sufficient to be detected at pH 7·2, fermentation of lactose significantly lowers the pH of the medium and can result in reduced enzyme activity and therefore lack of detection. The false negative rate of c. 10% would be difficult to detect in routine laboratories as it would represent 1% or less of yellow colonies being identified as E. coli (assuming E. coli accounts for 10% of the total coliform population in drinking water).

The impact of various land uses on the microbial and physicochemical quality of surface water bodies in developing countries: Prioritisation of water resources management areas

“…Most bacteria are known to thrive better around neutral pH of 7 (Fricker et al, 2010). As such, the pH ranges obtained in the current study for both tributaries favoured the survival of E. coli as demonstrated by the positive correlation between pH and E. coli counts.…”

Extended Spectrum Beta-Lactamase Escherichia coli in River Waters Collected from Two Cities in Ghana, 2018–2020

“…The Protocol is targeted towards implementation under circumstances without the presence of advanced laboratory infrastructure (e.g., MALDI-TOF for confirmation of species obtained) but nevertheless is expected to give results of high specificity through the use of assays based on the beta-glucuronidase activity of E. coli , which have a high sensitivity and specificity for determining E. coli concentrations in water. [ 61 , 62 ].…”

Phenotypic and Phylogenetic Identification of Coliform Bacteria Obtained Using 12 Coliform Methods Approved by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

“…A wide range of FP and FN rates have been reported (9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)48) (Table 3). In TE detection, LTB (or similar methods) generally gave much higher FP rates (Ͼ22%) than enzyme-based media (ϳ10%).…”

“…The rates for FN results are 3.3 to 26.2% and 20.3 to 48.6% for total coliforms and E. coli, respectively (9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15). The two likely reasons are an inability to recover target organisms from different drinking water matrices and an inability to distinguish target strains from nontarget organisms.…”

“…The former is often related to the occurrence of FN results, while the latter is the major cause of FP results. These two reasons have been evaluated in several studies (9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18). For example, Olstadt et al (13) compared 10 enzyme-based tests for the ability to recover different concentrations of spiked coliform and noncoliform strains from three diverse water matrices.…”