Understanding rebel nurse leadership‐as‐practice: Challenging and changing the status quo in hospitals

Abstract

Some nurses are responding rebelliously to the changing healthcare landscape by challenging the status quo and deviating from suboptimal practices, professional norms, and organizational rules. While some view rebel nurse leadership as challenging traditional structures to improve patient care, others see it as disruptive and harmful. These diverging opinions create dilemmas for nurses and nurse managers in daily practice. To understand the context, dilemmas, and interactions in rebel nurse leadership, we conducted a multiple case study in two Dutch hospitals. We delved into the mundane practices to expand the concept of leadership‐as‐practice. By shadowing rebel nurse practices, we identified three typical leadership practices which present the most common “lived” experiences and dilemmas of nurses and nurse managers. Overall, we noticed that deviating acts were more often quick fixes rather than sustainable changes. Our research points to what is needed to change the status quo in a sustainable manner. To change unworkable practices, nurses need to share their experienced dilemmas with their managers. In addition, nurse managers must build relationships with other nurses, value different perspectives, and support experimenting to promote collective learning.

Board talk: How members of executive hospital boards influence the positioning of nursing in crisis through talk

“…A processual relational leadership approach (Uhl-Bien, 2006) focuses on social order and organizational interaction (Cunliffe & Eriksen, 2011;Hosking, 1988) and forefronts communication as a process of ongoing construction (Oldenhof et al, 2016). Nursing leadership literature slowly acknowledges this approach as relevant to nursing practice (Kok et al, 2022(Kok et al, , 2023Martini et al, 2023).…”

“…Ethnographic and practice research approaches in leadership studies (Kok et al, 2023;Martini et al, 2023;Raelin, 2016Raelin, , 2019 can help unravel these processes of positioning, interaction, and interdependence and enhance collaboration between nursing and non-nursing agents in complex settings such as crisis management in hospitals.…”

Five pathways into one profession: Fifty years of debate on differentiated nursing practice

“…Both scholars pointed out that many examples within histories of nursing, however, tell different stories and reveal nurses' real power (D'Antonio et al, 2010; Smith, 2020). Recently, scholars have made similar arguments by studying nurses' role as change agents within healthcare organizations (De Kok et al, 2023; McMillan & Perron, 2020), healthcare systems (López‐Deflory et al, 2023), and politics (Rafferty, 2018; Ravn et al, 2020).…”