Understanding Online and Offline Social Networks in Illness Management of Older Patients With Asthma and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Mixed Methods Study Using Quantitative Social Network Assessment and Qualitative Analysis

Abstract

Background Individuals’ social networks and social support are fundamental determinants of self-management and self-efficacy. In chronic respiratory conditions, social support can be promoted and optimized to facilitate the self-management of breathlessness. Objective This study aimed to identify how online and offline social networks play a role in the health management of older patients with chronic respiratory conditions, explore the role of support from online peers in patients’ self-management, and understand the barriers to and potential benefits of digital social interventions. Methods We recruited participants from a hospital-run singing group to a workshop in London, the United Kingdom, and adapted PERSNET, a quantitative social network assessment tool. The second workshop was replaced by telephone interviews because of the COVID-19 lockdown. The transcripts were analyzed using thematic analysis. Results A total of 7 participants (2/7, 29%, men and 5/7, 71%, women), with an age range of 64 to 81 years, produced network maps that comprised between 5 and 10 individuals, including family members, health care professionals, colleagues, activity groups, offline and online friends, and peers. The visual maps facilitated reflections and enhanced participants’ understanding of the role of offline and online social networks in the management of chronic respiratory conditions. It also highlighted the work undertaken by the networks themselves in the self-management support. Participants with small, close-knit networks received physical, health, and emotional support, whereas those with more diverse and large networks benefited from accessing alternative and complementary sources of information. Participants in the latter type of network tended to communicate more openly and comfortably about their illness, shared the impact of their illness on their day-to-day life, and demonstrated distinct traits in terms of identity and perception of chronic disease. Participants described the potential benefits of expanding their networks to include online peers as sources of novel information, motivation, and access to supportive environments. Lack of technological skills, fear of being scammed, or preference for keeping illness-related problems for themselves and immediate family were reported by some as barriers to engaging with online peer support. Conclusions In this small-scale study, the social network assessment tool proved feasible and acceptable. These data show the value of using a social network tool as a research tool that can help assess and understand network structure and engagement in the self-management support and could be developed into an intervention to support self-management. Patients’ preferences to share illness experiences with their online peers, as well as the contexts in which this can be acceptable, should be considered when developing and offering digital social interventions. Future studies can explore the evolution of the social networks of older people with chronic illnesses to understand whether their willingness to engage with online peers can change over time.

Motivating factors for physical activity participation among individuals with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A qualitative study applying the motivation, opportunity, and ability model

“…Furthermore, measures suggested to meet the individualized needs of COPD patients include regular assessment of the degree of respiratory difficulty, balance control ability, and osteoporosis status [ 55 – 57 ]; sharing activity data with participants using activity trackers [ 58 , 59 ]; utilizing new technologies for systematic and long-term risk monitoring [ 60 ]; encouraging female and comorbid patients to participate in PA programs [ 61 , 62 ]; providing online peer support or digital social interventions for younger participants [ 63 ]; and paying attention to the acceptance of patient role behavior in Asian culture, along with providing psychological care [ 64 ].…”

Implementation of digital home monitoring and management of respiratory disease

“…Table 1 summarizes some existing digital home monitoring interventions in a number of respiratory conditions that have benefit in supporting patients to manage their conditions, reducing hospitalization, and facilitating remote consultation [10 ▪ ,13,18,27–59]. These interventions have proved to be feasible and effective in research contexts and potentially could be developed for implementation in routine practice.…”

“…Lay-led monitoring Patients with similar conditions share logs, asthma experience and opinion on treatment in the social forum [58].…”

Non-randomised feasibility study testing a primary care intervention to promote engagement in an online health community for adults with troublesome asthma: protocol

“…Co-design with PPIs has been incorporated into several stages of the development of this study, including through online consultations with the AUKCAR PPI group and public engagement activities. 39 These emphasised the importance of primary care clinicians engendering norms and values in OHC engagement; feelings of loneliness and fear in asthma symptoms and the positive impact of empathy received by peers through OHCs; and the reluctance of some patients to discuss their condition in an OHC (taken into account when planning recruitment strategies). PPI input will carry on throughout the delivery of the study, as well as during analysis and dissemination of findings.…”