Understanding English as a Foreign Language Students’ Idea Generation Strategies for Creative Writing With Natural Language Generation Tools

Abstract

Natural language generation (NLG) is a process within artificial intelligence where computer systems produce human-comprehensible language texts from information. English as a foreign language (EFL) students’ use of NLG tools might facilitate their idea generation, which is fundamental to creative writing. However, little is known about how EFL students interact with NLG tools to generate ideas. This study explores strategies adopted by EFL students when searching for ideas using NLG tools, evaluating ideas generated by NLG tools and selecting NLG tools for idea generation. Four Hong Kong secondary school students attended workshops where they learned to write stories comprising their own words and words generated by NLG tools. After the workshops, they answered questions to reflect on their writing experience with NLG tools. In a thematic analysis of the written reflections, we found students may have existing ideas when searching for ideas and evaluating ideas with NLG tools. Students showed some aversion to ideas generated by NLG tools and selected NLG tools that generated a greater quantity of ideas. The findings inform our understanding of EFL students’ concerns when using NLG tools for idea generation and can inform educators’ instruction to implement NLG tools for classroom creative writing.

ChatGPT Improves Creative Problem-Solving Performance in University Students: An Experimental Study

“…Based on the present study, it may be possible to propose several explanations of why ChatGPT improved all three dimensions: quality, elaboration, and originality (Todd et al, 2019). As suggested by Woo et al (2023), ChatGPT may enhance divergent thinking processes by exposing students to a wide range of possible solutions. This exposure then encourages students to consider a larger pool of solutions, allowing them to select more promising prototypical solutions (Mumford et al, 1991;2019).…”

Transformative Experiences: Zoho's AI Writing Solutions

“…In a systematic review, it was found that students are increasingly using various AI-powered writing assistance tools, including automated writing evaluation tools, corrective feedback tools, machine translators, and automatic text generators [24]. Students applied natural language generation (NLG) in creative writing and found different strategies for using NLG-generated words [25]. A study on students' perceptions of AI in a writing class found that students had positive perceptions and enjoyed using an AI app for writing [26].…”