Understanding discrimination in hiring apprentices: how training companies use ethnicity to avoid organisational trouble

Abstract

Children of immigrants from non-EU countries face particular problems to access apprenticeship training in German-speaking countries. In this context this article asks how recruiters in small and medium sized companies (SME) make sense of national and ethnic origin when hiring new apprentices. The author proposes Boltanski and Thévenot's theory of justification in order to conceptualise ethnic discrimination in hiring. Accordingly, the social body of a company consists of multiple interweaved (industrial, domestic, market) 'worlds' of social coordination and justification. In order to avoid organisational trouble and to guarantee the further existence of the company, these worlds claim different principle of personnel assessment, some of them penalising applicants of specific ethnic origin. Empirically, the article refers to apprentice recruitment in Switzerland and Germany. It illustrates that employers in SME expect trouble in the domestic and in the market world of the company when hiring school leavers they perceive as foreigners. Hence, discriminatory categories such as ethnicity are used as symbolic and organisational resources for trouble avoidance in hiring apprentices.

Upper secondary education for youth at risk: A comparative analysis of education and training programmes in Austria, Norway, Sweden and Switzerland

“…Moreover, youth from disadvantaged families often lack a relevant social network with respect to careers of interest. Finally, research shows that disadvantaged youth and especially those with migrant backgrounds face the risk of discrimination when applying for an apprenticeship place (Imdorf, 2017).…”

Re-conceptualising VET: responses to covid-19

“…The complex stratification of apprenticeship opportunities in DACH (Germany, Austria, Switzerland) countries, with hitech employers working directly with universities outside VET and migrants concentrated in routinised service occupations, is likely to be reinstituted as economic and educational activity rises. The position of VET's many migrants and other disadvantaged youth reliant on work placements may become even less secure and it remains to be seen how VET practices respond to underlying issues of racism which have become increasingly salient internationally (Imdorf 2017;Chadderton and Edmonds 2015;Grønborg 2015).…”

The social-origin gap in university graduation by gender and immigrant status: a cohort analysis for Switzerland

“…Alternatively, higher aspirations could be due to the quest for status maintenance as migrant families may have belonged to an educational elite in their country of origin -a fact that is hidden by the overall higher levels of education in the host society (Engzell and Ichou, 2019). Migrant families may also be less likely to be 'diverted' to vocational training if they expect greater benefits -and usefulness in their country of origin -from academic education (Jonsson and Rudolphi, 2010: 503) or, alternatively, if they anticipate discrimination in the apprenticeship market (Imdorf, 2017;Hupka-Brunner et al, 2010). These elements lead us to expect a weaker effect of parental background on the educational attainment of migrants:…”