Underestimation of Species Richness in Neotropical Frogs Revealed by mtDNA Analyses

Abstract

BackgroundAmphibians are rapidly vanishing. At the same time, it is most likely that the number of amphibian species is highly underestimated. Recent DNA barcoding work has attempted to define a threshold between intra- and inter-specific genetic distances to help identify candidate species. In groups with high extinction rates and poorly known species boundaries, like amphibians, such tools may provide a way to rapidly evaluate species richness.MethodologyHere we analyse published and new 16S rDNA sequences from 60 frog species of Amazonia-Guianas to obtain a minimum estimate of the number of undescribed species in this region. We combined isolation by distance, phylogenetic analyses, and comparison of molecular distances to evaluate threshold values for the identification of candidate species among these frogs.Principal FindingsIn most cases, geographically distant populations belong to genetically highly distinct lineages that could be considered as candidate new species. This was not universal among the taxa studied and thus widespread species of Neotropical frogs really do exist, contrary to previous assumptions. Moreover, the many instances of paraphyly and the wide overlap between distributions of inter- and intra-specific distances reinforce the hypothesis that many cryptic species remain to be described. In our data set, pairwise genetic distances below 0.02 are strongly correlated with geographical distances. This correlation remains statistically significant until genetic distance is 0.05, with no such relation thereafter. This suggests that for higher distances allopatric and sympatric cryptic species prevail. Based on our analyses, we propose a more inclusive pairwise genetic distance of 0.03 between taxa to target lineages that could correspond to candidate species.ConclusionsUsing this approach, we identify 129 candidate species, two-fold greater than the 60 species included in the current study. This leads to estimates of around 170 to 460 frog taxa unrecognized in Amazonia-Guianas.SignificanceAs a consequence the global amphibian decline detected especially in the Neotropics may be worse than realised.

Systematic relationships of Oriental tiny frogs of the family Microhylidae (Amphibia, Anura) as revealed by mtDNA genealogy

“…In our results Micryletta inornata was paraphyletic with respect to M. steinegeri. The sample of M. inornata from northern Thailand (M. i. inornata) and M. steinegeri were genetically close (uncorrected p-distance in 16S of 2.9%), while the sample of M. inornata from southern Thailand (M. i. lineata of Taylor, 1962) was more divergent from them with uncorrected p-distances of 4.9-5.1%, which values exceed those reported between different frog species (Fouquet et al, 2007). These results support the separation of two subspecies of M. inornata into two distinct species, but such a revision includes problems.…”

Vast underestimation of Madagascar's biodiversity evidenced by an integrative amphibian inventory

“…An important acceleration in the rate of new discoveries, mainly from tropical areas, is obvious from many recent studies (11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16). These discoveries are not the result of taxonomic inflation (9,14,17), but correspond to real divergent species (18,19).…”

Light at the end of the tunnel: insights into the molecular systematics of East African puddle frogs (Anura: Phrynobatrachidae)

“…This gene region has significant species-level variability and conserved flanking sites are present, which allow universal primers to work for the majority of species. These characteristics make this marker a valuable tool for taxonomic investigation in both large-scale phylogenetic studies and population-level haplotype analyses of amphibians (Vences et al, 2005a;Fouquet, 2007). The great numbers of amphibian 16S rRNA sequences currently present in GenBank (13 393 entries as of January 2010) support the usefulness of this gene in taxonomic investigations.…”