Underascertainment of Deaths using Social Security Records: A Recommended Solution to a Little-Known Problem

Abstract

Complete and accurate ascertainment of vital status is of great importance in cohort studies. Recently, during the vital status ascertainment phase of an ongoing occupational mortality study, the authors discovered a potentially serious problem with use of the Pension Benefit Information Company's tracing service or any tracing that relies on records from the Social Security Administration (SSA) Death Master File to identify deaths. Their investigation revealed that a number of US states restrict the information in the SSA's Death Master File that is available to researchers and the public as a source of death information. As a result of these findings, the authors recommend a revised two-stage vital status tracing protocol. For stage I, data on all subjects for whom vital status is unconfirmed should be sent to the SSA. For stage II, information on all subjects to whom SSA assigned an unknown vital status as well as all subjects whom SSA identified as known decedents should be submitted to the National Death Index. This new protocol will enable researchers to maximize vital status ascertainment while containing costs associated with death identification.

Predictors of locating women six to eight years after contact: internet resources at recruitment may help to improve response rates in longitudinal research

“…Finally, although vital statistics linkages were helpful to identify deceased individuals, access to these resources may be limited by privacy legislation, and the data may not be available in a timely fashion [21]. We found that vital statistics data were incomplete a year after the end of study recruitment.…”

Evaluation of mortality among marines and navy personnel exposed to contaminated drinking water at USMC base Camp Lejeune: a retrospective cohort study

“…Personal identifier information from the DMDC database was matched to data in the Social Security Administration (SSA) Death Master File (DMF) and SSA Office of Research, Evaluation and Statistics (ORES) Presumed Living Search to determine vital status [16,17]. For those not matched, a commercial tracing service was used to determine vital status.…”

Mortality Patterns Among Workers Exposed to Acrylamide: Updated Follow Up

“…24,25 Subjects with "unknown" vital status were untraceable mainly due to missing Social Security numbers, a limitation of the original study due mostly to Warners employees hired before the establishment of the SSA. For deaths occurring before 1979 (beginning of NDI), death certificates were obtained from the corresponding state health departments and, to conform with the original study, were coded by a nosologist to underlying cause of death using the 8th revision rules of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD).…”