Under-reporting of road traffic accidents in traffic police records- a cross sectional study from North India

Abstract

Background: Underreporting of deaths and injuries resulting from road traffic accidents is a major issue globally. Understanding the extent of underreporting and the causes along with the assessment of quality of data available will help in developing a better system of reporting and accurate estimation of burden and risk factors which aid in developing prevention programmes. Methods: A cross sectional study was done keeping hospital records as a baseline data to which the under reporting in the police records on traffic injuries was measured. The population under study was the total number of accidents that took place in Chandigarh in the month of June-July 2011 and had reported to the emergency department of three major government hospitals. These three hospitals have been selected purposefully as majority of the road traffic accident victims are being admitted/ treated in these hospitals. Results: A total of 537 cases and 375 cases were recorded in police and hospital records respectively for the month of June-July 2011. Only 15% cases from the police records were matched with the hospital records. Among the matched 64% were completely matched and 36% were partially matched cases. None of fatal injuries registered in both the records were among the matched cases. Most of the road traffic accident cases (79.4%) involved males aged 20-49 years. The official records of road accidents have been found to be incomplete in terms of number of accident and information on age, sex, address of the victim, type and severity of injury. Conclusions: A standardised reporting format of all RTIs should be developed and maintained by both the police and hospitals. All hospitals should mandatorily report all RTI cases reported to them to the police to ensure completeness.

Completeness of police reporting of traffic crashes in Nepal: Evaluation using a community crash recording system

“…The under-reporting rate of 80.4% was similar to that reported by Singh et al. ( 2018 ) (85%) in Chandigarh, India comparing police and hospital data. Periyasamy et al.…”

“…Singh et al. ( 2018 ) conducted a cross-sectional study in Chandigarh, India, reporting only 15% of hospital records matched police records, while in Malaysia, Kamaluddin et al. ( 2019 ) reported a matching rate of only 4.1%.…”

Socioeconomic patterns and determinants of adult mortality due to external-causes in India: Analysis of nationally-representative, population-based survey data

“…Underreporting of deaths due to external causes in NCRB data is discussed earlier (Patel et 2012;Singh et al 2018). Our figures cannot be directly compared with the findings from the previous studies (Jagnoor et al 2011;Jagnoor et al 2012) Palanivel et al (2013) shows the external causes account for around 15% of total deaths from2002 to 2007.…”

Pedestrian mortality in Russia: a continuous decline over the last 25 years?

“…Of course, this statement is not true for all countries. For example, in China and India, there is an underestimation of injured pedestrians, including fatalities, according to published police reports (Bhalla et al 2017;Hu, Ma, Zhou 2012;Li et al 2016;Singh et al 2018). The problem of determining the category of road user in the vital statistics exists not only in Russia, but also in the United States, where protected road users are a problem group (Mack et al 2019).…”