In the last few decades, massive effort has been expended in heterogeneous catalysis to develop new materials presenting high conversion, selectivity, and stability even under high-temperature and high-pressure conditions. In this context, CO 2 hydrogenation is an interesting reaction where the catalyst local structure is strongly related to the development of an active and stable material under hydrothermal conditions at T/P > 300 °C/30 bar. In order to clarify the relationship between catalyst local ordering and its activity/stability, we herein report a combined laboratory and synchrotron investigation of aliovalent element (Ce/Zn/ Ga)-containing ZrO 2 matrixes. The results reveal the influence of similar average structures with different short-range orderings on the catalyst properties. Moreover, a further step toward the comprehension of the oxygen vacancy formation mechanism in Ce-and Ga-ZrO 2 catalysts is reported. Finally, the reported results illustrate a robust method to guide local structure determination and ultimately help to avoid overuse of the "solid solution" definition.