Uncertainty and Variability of Energy and Material Use by Fused Deposition Modeling Printers in Makerspaces

Abstract

Summary Desktop‐grade fused deposition modeling (FDM) printers are popular because of compact sizes and affordable prices. If we are moving toward a future where desktop FDM printers are in every school and office, like conventional printers, then these machines will consume a large amount of energy and material. However, it is very difficult to evaluate the environmental impacts of FDM printers since there are so many different brands and types of printers using different raw materials under different scenarios. This study uses data from two different printing sites to evaluate the scenario and parameter uncertainty and variability in energy and material balances for FDM printers. Data from the two makerspaces provide insight into the material and energy consumption data using polylactic acid and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) with four types of printers. The use of actual performance data allowed for the additional study of scrap ratio. Regressions provide insight into predictive factors for energy and material consumption. Monte Carlo simulations show the range of energy life cycle inventory values for the desktop‐grade FDM printers. From the regressions, Type A Pro was the most energy‐intensive machine. For material waste, an open‐access makerspace using ABS was associated with higher scrap ratio. Regression analysis indicates that the rate of material usage is not a strong predictor of waste rates. The amount of waste generated across both sites indicates that more ubiquitous access to FDM printing may create a significant addition to the waste stream.

Recent advances in additive manufacturing of engineering thermoplastics: challenges and opportunities

“…However, waste materials have been suggested to be reduced based on the optimal parameter selection for a print. 220 6.6 The future of this technology For both SLS and E3DP, there is the increasing demand for versatile and sustainable materials. Substantial efforts have been made regarding research into this technology to serve enduse parts, whether automotive parts, medical parts or devices, consumer goods or aerospace.…”

How to increase sustainability in the Finnish wine supply chain? Insights from a country of origin based greenhouse gas emissions analysis

“…Following similar works on the wine sector (Falcone et al, 2016;Meneses et al, 2016), the second analysis step consisted of employing a Monte Carlo simulation (10,000 iterations), which is the predominant method used in LCA studies (Gregory et al, 2013;Henriksson et al, 2015;Pryshlakivsky and Searcy, 2017;Ross and Cheah, 2017;Song et al, 2018). This method generates random variables selected by the imposed distribution functions for each input parameter.…”

“…These LCA and related systems approaches can help supply chain members to identify cost saving opportunities through energy efficiency initiatives (Matthews et al, 2008;Song et al, 2018) or provide opportunities for restructuring entire supply chains (Steiner and Jäger, 2018;Linton et al, 2007).…”

Polymer Recycling in Additive Manufacturing: an Opportunity for the Circular Economy

“…However, some parameters need to be optimised, and considerations must be followed in the use of recycled polymers for FDM. For the use of recycled filaments in FDM, certain parameters should be optimised (Song et al 2019), such as building orientation, temperature conditions, and slicing parameters. Several studies have attempted to utilise recycled polymers in FDM.…”