Uncertainty analysis of a large break loss of coolant accident in a pressurized water reactor using non-parametric methods

Abstract

The safety analysis of nuclear power plant is moving towards a realistic approach in which the simulations performed using best estimate computer codes must be accompanied by an uncertainty analysis, known as the Best Estimate Plus Uncertainties approach. The most popular statistical method used in these analyses is the Wilks' method, which is based on the principle of order statistics for determining a certain coverage of the Figures-of-Merit with an appropriate degree of confidence. However, there exist other statistical techniques that could provide similar or even better results. This paper explores the performance of alternative nonparametric methods as compared to the Wilks' method of obtaining such Figure-of-Merits tolerance intervals. Three methods are investigated, i.e. Hutson and Beran-Hall methods and a bootstrap method. All the techniques have been used to perform the uncertainty analysis of a Large-Break Loss of Coolant Accident. The Figure-of-Merit of interest in this application is the maximum value reached by the Peaking Clad Temperature. In order to analyze the results obtained by the different methods, four performance metrics are proposed to measure the coverage, dispersion, conservativeness, and robustness of the tolerance intervals.

Optimal Uncertainty Quantification of a Risk Measurement From a Thermal-Hydraulic Code Using Canonical Moments

“…The P.O.F is then optimized globally using a differential evolution solver [29]. Algorithm 1 summarizes step 1 to step 4 in order to compute the lowest probability of failure (4). The main cost of the algorithm arises from the high number of metamodel calls for G, evaluated on a d-dimensional grid of size ) and its corresponding sequences of canonical moments, p i = (p…”

Robust on-line diagnosis tool for the early accident detection in nuclear power plants

“…Indeed, measured data possess an intrinsic level of uncertainty, due to its evolutionary nature (i.e. time-space variability) and unavoidable measurement imprecision or even errors [20]. In the case of real-time monitoring, the degree of uncertainty affecting the prediction…”

An Information Geometry Approach to Robustness Analysis for the Uncertainty Quantification of Computer Codes

“…One precise case is where operators have to study loss of coolant accidents (LOCA), which result in a break in the primary loop of pressurized water nuclear reactors. This scenario can be simulated using system thermal-hydraulic computer codes which involve dozens of physical parameters including such things as condensation and heat transfer coefficients (Mazgaj et al, 2016;Sanchez-Saez et al, 2018). However, the values of many such parameters are known with only limited precision (Larget, 2019) as they are typically calculated by way of other quantities measured via small-scale physical experiments.…”