“…We compared frogs in life and our color photographs (Supplementary Figs. S4-S27) with published descriptions and taxonomic keys (e.g., Cisneros-Heredia and Yánez-Muñoz, 2010;Funkhouser, 1956;Grant et al, 2006Grant et al, , 2017Myers, 1987;Silverstone, 1976;Tarvin et al, 2017a). Briefly, the color and pattern characters included the presence or completeness of the oblique lateral stripe (Edwards 1974; different than dorsolateral stripe), paracloacal mark (Grant et al 2006), and ventrolateral stripe (Edwards 1974); the presence of flash spots in the inguinal region and concealed surfaces of the thigh and shank, and color pattern of dorsum, venter, flanks, head, and limbs.…”