Ten unsymmetrical N,N'‐bis (imino) acenaphthene‐nickel (II) halide complexes, [1‐[2,6‐{(4‐MeOC6H4)2CH}2–4‐MeC6H2N]‐2‐(ArN)C2C10H6]NiX2, each appended with one N‐2,6‐bis(4,4'‐dimethoxybenzhydryl)‐4‐methylphenyl group, have been synthesized and characterized. The molecular structures of Ni1, Ni3, Ni5 and Ni6 highlight the variation in steric protection afforded by the inequivalent N‐aryl groups; a distorted tetrahedral geometry is conferred about each nickel center. On activation with diethylaluminum chloride (Et2AlCl) or methylaluminoxane (MAO), all complexes showed high activity at 30°C for the polymerization of ethylene with the least bulky bromide precatalysts (Ni1 and Ni4), generally the most productive, forming polyethylenes with narrow dispersities [Mw/Mn: < 3.4 (Et2AlCl), < 4.1 (MAO)] and various levels of branching. Significantly, this level of branching can be influenced by the type of co‐catalyst employed, with Et2AlCl having a predilection towards polymers displaying significantly higher branching contents than with MAO [Tm: 33.0–82.5°C (Et2AlCl) vs. 117.9–119.4°C (MAO)]. On the other hand, the molecular weights of the materials obtained with each co‐catalyst were high and, in some cases, entering the ultra‐high molecular weight range [Mw range: 6.8–12.2 × 105 g mol−1 (Et2AlCl), 7.2–10.9 × 105 g mol−1 (MAO)]. Furthermore, good tensile strength (εb up to 553.5%) and elastic recovery (up to 84%) have been displayed by selected more branched polymers highlighting their elastomeric properties.