“…Here, a different problem arises; tetrathioarsenate is completely deprotonated above pH 5.2 (Thilo et al, 1970), so H 2 AsS 4 À could not be significant in the pH 7-10 range covered by Wilkin et al Apparently,neither posited equilibrium Reaction (6) or (7), satisfactorily explains the observed concentration relationships between the S/As = 3 and 4 species. On the other hand, if thioarsenate sulfidations are acid catalyzed, like the analogous thiomolybdate reactions (Erickson and Helz, 2000;Vorlicek and Helz, 2002), then appearance in a relatively short time interval of a fully sulfidized (S/As = 4) species at pH 7 but not pH 10 is easily explained by kinetics.…”