“…(2) Efficient recycling of elements such as Th and Be from subducted sediments into arc magmas in most arcs worldwide is inferred from correlation of, e.g., Th/La with Pb and Nd isotope ratios in arc lavas [Class et al, 2000;Elliott et al, 1997;Hawkesworth et al, 1997], and from correlation of Th enrichment in arc lavas with the flux of subducted, sedimentary Th [Plank and Langmuir, 1998;Plank and Langmuir, 1993]. Because Th and Be are relatively insoluble in aqueous fluids, even under simulated subduction zone conditions, but are highly mobile incompatible elements during partial melting of both metasediments and metabasalt, it is argued that their efficient recycling requires melting of subducting sediment [e.g., Johnson and Plank, 1999;Brenan et al, 1995a;Brenan et al, 1995b;].…”