IntroductionSynergistic Divergence (SD) is a rare ocular motility disorder associated with congenital adduction palsy (Cruysberg et al. 1959;Mohan et al. 1998;Oystreck et al. 2009;Gupta et al. 2010) and manifests as unilateral divergence of the affected eye on attempted adduction, resulting in bilateral abduction and a "wall-eyed" appearance when looking to the contralateral side.The earliest report of congenital synergistic divergence is from 1950 (Worth C. and Chavasse F.B.); however, since this time there have been no reports of acquired cases, hence the conclusion in literature to date is that this is a purely congenital condition. The following case report will challenge this conclusion and prompt questions regarding the mechanisms behind acquired SD.
Presentation, Investigation and ManagementAn 18-year-old female was referred from her community optometrist with a 2-3 year history of diplopia and her left eye turning outwards, which had been worsening in the last year. Medical history was uneventful, including only tonsillitis and traumatic forceps delivery at birth. Her mother reported the patient had asymmetric pupils, with the left always being bigger and more sluggish, for as long as she could remember. On referral to Manchester Royal Eye Hospital, ocular motility demonstrated a restriction of left adduction and depression, slight left ptosis and anisocoria. Cover test revealed an incomitant exotropia for near and distance with diplopia. Initial diagnosis was a decompensating exophoria; however, this was challenged due to the presence of a -2.5 underaction of the left inferior rectus and sluggish left. In the following 12 months, the restriction of left medial rectus increased to -2 and the initial inferior rectus underaction developed into a restriction with the addition of a -0.5 restriction of left superior rectus. An MRI scan was ordered in November 2013, and this revealed a third nerve schwannoma in the cavernous sinus. The patient was sent for genetic testing to rule out neurofibromatosis type 2 and schwannomatosis.The tests were reported as negative for these conditions. The orthoptic report explicitly stated no aberrant regeneration in 2014. The patient had nine botulinum toxin (BT) injections to the left lateral rectus between 2014 and 2017 to control her diplopia. In 2017, she had a left lateral rectus recession of 5 mm and transposition of the upper muscle border to lower edge of insertion and a left medial rectus resection of 6 mm on adjustable sutures. An inferior oblique transposition was attempted, but a significant torsion effect was observed; therefore, the muscle was returned to its original position. Ocular motility Waters, M. 2020. Acquired Synergistic Divergence: Contrary to Current Literature.Current literature reports synergistic divergence as a rare, congenital ocular motility pattern associated with adduction palsy. Its mechanism has been likened to Duane's syndrome, and some suggest it be referred to as Duane's Type 4 (Gupta et al. 2010;Schliesser et al. 2016;Wilcox et al. 1981;...