Two Steps Forward, One Step Backward: Societal Capacity and Israel's Implementation of the Barcelona Convention and the Mediterranean Action Plan

Abstract

A large literature exists regarding explanations for the emergence of cooperation in the Mediterranean basin, but there is less information regarding the effectiveness of Mediterranean cooperation and its programs. Through a case study of Israel's implementation and compliance with the Barcelona Convention and the Mediterranean Action Plan, we evaluate the effectiveness of these international institutions. We find that international institutions and their efforts to target state capacity as the mechanism to improve compliance and effectiveness are often misguided unless their efforts are also directed towards enhancing societal capacity. We then explicate the way in which societal actors such as environmental NGOs can improve domestic compliance and effectiveness. These findings are illuminated through an assessment of the activities of several environmental NGOs in Israel to target Mediterranean pollution and coastal management policies. Where NGOs have taken action, they have often proved successful in forcing the Israeli government and the business sector to honor its environmental commitments. Copyright (c) 2003 Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

A model for the implementation of ICM in the Mediterranean region

“…A high proportion of respondents used the widely discussed term of additionality which emphasises the need to have transparent funding schemes so that allocated resources are truly additional. Results agree with the conclusions of Weinthal and Parag (2003) that there is a need to target not just state but also societal capacity. The development of national strategies needs controlled administrative coordination and awareness raising techniques (Gonzalez-Riancho et al 2008) while national authority needs to actively support stakeholders with power allocations through legislative channels (Ernoul 2008).…”

Impacts of Climate Change on Vector Borne Diseases in the Mediterranean Basin — Implications for Preparedness and Adaptation Policy

“…The fact that all members are connected directly to the MAP Secretariat enables productive cooperation despite gaps and conflicts. For example, under the umbrella of MAP, Israel strengthened an environmental cooperation with Egypt and signed a sub-regional agreement with Egypt and Cyprus in 1995 [ 99 ]. Yet, there is significant variation in the capacity of diverse countries to implement the MAP protocols.…”

The demarcation of arbitrary boundaries for coastal zone management: The Israeli case

“…The Israeli government ratified the 1976 Barcelona Convention and its Protocol for the Protection of the Mediterranean Sea Against Pollution from Land-Based Sources, and the 1973 International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships and its 1978 Protocol. It subsequently translated these conventions into two crucial pieces of domestic legislation aimed at protecting marine elements of the coastal zone: the 1980 Prevention of Sea Water Pollution from Oil Ordinance (New Version), and the 1988 Prevention of Pollution from Land-based Sources Law (Talitman et al, 2003;Weinthal and Parag, 2003).…”